Unfortunately, that exceedingly helpful and lovely map site is gone . . .
So here are a few other options.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
This is Second Age from Fonstad:
Map 1
~*~
Also 2nd Age:
Map 2
~*~
Close to the original map – but you need to move the mountain range closer to the west coast (this is more like the southern lands before the sinking of Beleriand:
Map 3
~*~
This gives a good look at the restructured lands after the sinking of Beleriand and Numenor (make sure you expand it to regular size to see all the features):
Map 4
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Personally, I like Map 1 and Map 4
~*~ Pio @ cartography central . . .