... and running hard to catch up
Disclaimer first: I love Faramir. What to follow is not an essay in castin slurs upon him.
Now to one thing which struck me: Faramir is a bit of a play-actor and 'self-made man' (in a mental sense). He trains his mind as much as he supposedly trains his body, pursuing perfection. He tries on the mask of a better person, and lives up to the standard.
I refer to the following lines:
Quote:
|
'But fear no more! I would not take this thing, if it lay by the highway
|
The general impression: Faramir is, of course, boasting and showing off, but, also, setting himself another standard, another height to conquer. (Just as good he manages to conquer it when the Ring presents itself)
Denethor is not blind. What I rather would praise in Faramir, Denethor states as case for indictment:
Quote:
|
I know you well. Ever your desire is to appear lordly and generous as a king of old, gracious, gentle. That may well befit one of high race, if he sits in power and peace. But in desperate hours gentleness may be repaid with death
|
Emphasis mine
Now I run ahead of things a bit (or even a lot, since it is the next book where the quote is taken from), but that is an accussation to strike where it will hurt, it seems, a blame of 'appearing', but not, in fact 'being' is what Faramir would fear most.
We are alike with him in this respect, only I fail to live up to the standard more often than not (I refer to 'Masks' thread as well here)
Denethor loves his both sons. He's desparate to find someone else besides himself to blame for Boromir's death. I suppose it is fairly unconsious too. But this also for later discussion
cheers