Maybe....
...if there was no Feanor and Feanorians... *
*with exception of Maglor
Like said, six hotheads.. Just like their father...
I mean, really... Rashness runs in the blood...Just look at Curufin.
Or Celegorm.
I mean, he was quite good with cheating Luthien with his past lover.
Maeglin was born late in the first age, wasn't he? Aredhel probably got married to Eol just a few months earlier.
But hosts of Feanor and Fingolfin came to Middle-Earth EARLY in the first age. Celegorm is known to have devoted himself to hunting, and Aredhel is claimed to not love anyone. Coincidence? I think not.
There you have it. Celegorm claimed to love Luthien, but his only true love died when Eol cast his javelin...a cheat. No wonder Luthien didn't want him.
Oh, and this wasn't meant to offend Aredhel...just Celegorm.
