Quote:
Originally Posted by Ivriniel
The names are unfamiliar to me, but I love the obscure ones, more as I age. Gilmith and Ivriniel are two of my favourites, and I often wonder whether there were other Half Elves, unnamed in the works.
|
I was vaguely familiar with Ivriniel (due to her dad clearly having an
obsession with Finduilas Faelivrin of Nargothrond), but had to look up Gilmith... I'll bounce over to
the Imrazor thread to discuss her, but I agree that her case suggests that there almost
must have been other half-elven couples. You can point at Beren and Luthien, Tuor and Idril, Aragorn and Arwen as all Fated, but there's nothing that makes a part-Elvish Dol Amroth line important to the fate of the world. The case of Aegnor and Andreth shows that the desire certainly existed on both sides - and it would be silly to imagine that all of the Eldar were as cowardly as Aegnor...
hS