well let me say what I like about these idea
Quote:
The sober exposition of the Council of Elrond is recast as a fantastic medieval masque representing the history of the Rings. This highly stylized sequence combines elements of Kabuki theater, rock opera, and circus performance, and could almost be imagined as a later retelling of the legend by a tribe of decadent Dark Elves. It is strangely effective, and gets the necessary back-story across, but it is definitely not a straightforward adaptation of Tolkien’s work.
|
Also that skinless horse sounds awesome however it shouldnt replace the flying steed it should be the nazgul's horse in the first place
that seems like a not so bad idea if you ask me
Oh and sometimes in PJ's version you want to bury captain obvious and beat sense into him
Oh
(and this is from a 18 year old guy's point of view) they could have made the ladies a bit sexier(but not to the point of absurdity that this script mentions)