<font face="Verdana"><table><TR><TD><FONT SIZE="1" face="Verdana, Helvetica, sans-serif">Moderator
Posts: 57</TD><TD></TD></TR></TABLE>
Re: The Attack on Gondolin
FG-A01: Agree
FG-A02: I cannot find any source for this statement either; I agree that the text should be kept unless something turns up.
FG-A03: Agree
FG-A04: Well, we could possibly make keep a Sindarin name for 'Gates of Summer' using _annon_=gate, and a Sindarin form of either Q. _Laire_ or Q. _Saiwen_, just to give us another option; but I agree that deleting both names is the way to go.
FG-A05: Agree.
FG-A06: Agree.
FG-A07: Agree.
FG-A08: Agree; again I think we need not make the two outer deletions.
Regarding the Hobbit version: I think we should ignore this, classing it with the later change in the Hobbit whereby the Sun and Moon were implied to have existed from the beginning.
</p>
|