I'm a bit of both. I really liked the book version and everything (esp. the part with the song and Sam being happy
) but I also really like the movie version. Actually, I must say I like the movie version just a tad bit more. I just love the feeling of that scene! It always makes me smile and want to cry; it's just so touching. Also, I like how Merry and Pippin were honored too, granted they may not have gone to Mordor and back, but for two young hobbits they did a lot of courageous things and deserved about as much honor as Frodo and Sam recieved.