Quote:
|
my guess is that PJ et al just chose to modify the scene in order to PJ-ify
|
It's called suspense! or building the atmosphere up..... didn't gandalf turn up at night in the book too anyway? ok so he didn't grab him, but does this really matter? Is it really that different to the book? ok, I think it might have worked better to see the Nazgul at Gaffer's door, but other than that, to condense the time and move the movie on, the hobbits left straight away......
what about the 17 year gap - to a movie is it really that important?