Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Wilwa
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerwen
1. He's an Elf. Simple.
2. He's not an Elf, but, in direct contradiction of what she says here, she was confident of being able to manipulate him.
3. He's not an Elf, but she believed him to be the Unknown Orc, who had already decided to go over to the Elves (denies this here and here).
|
The third one is actually not a possibility, since the Unknown Orc only chose their side this past Night. |
I know that. That's why I said "has already decided". Meaning that he could have decided to go over to the wolves on Day One, even before making a formal decision.
Lottielf went to some trouble to discount this possibility, so it may be that's exactly what she thought was happening.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Wilwa
I'm going to say a massive case of over analysing each other. And I agree with everything else you said. I really don't want this to take up the rest of the Day, it was a bluff, clearly, and it makes more sense to be an innocent bluff rather than a guilty one.
|
Listen, my only intention here is make some kind of sense of the
phantom-engima. If I keep poking at him, it's because he keeps thrashing madly when poked at– which naturally makes me wonder. I do not think it "makes more sense as an innocent bluff"– I've said why. I agree it shouldn't be the only thing we talk about, though.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Wilwa
And I actually think that Lottie turning up guilty does make Sally look a bit better (though not all better, because her attributing Lottie's death to Phantom is weird, since he didn't vote and seemed to actually have been leaning towards a Boro vote (and may have voted him instead, if Izzy hadn't of voted)).
|
Why do you think it makes her look better,
Wilwa? I don't see that at all, myself.