Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerwen
Well, if you mean the Great Devil Debate, it started at #49 and has now seemingly come full circle. As for the original original thread topic, I fear it has passed into the West and left us.
(Seriously, is there anything left to say about Tauriel now? So much discussion of such a pointless character...)
|
In true Tolkien fashion, Tauriel is a Tragic character.
It is a tragedy that she was included simply for the sake of pandering to "diversity," where so many other possibilities existed for Female Characters that were not pandering.
But my personal preference would for the Movie to have been shot without altering Tolkien's canon.
They had
PLENTY to make a Trilogy out of
The Hobbit without including anything from the associated materials for the period. You reasonably could have made six movies out of
The Hobbit, and nine out of
The Lord of the Rings.
And as for "inserting" female Characters....
If they were going to include the Assault upon Dol Guldur... Is not Galadriel enough?
I just wish that someone were able to make a movie of it that was just the book.... As written.... Songs and all. No additional characters. No diverting to Dol Guldur.
Those scenes could easily have been included as additional productions in their own right if we are going to go there.
MB