Quote:
Originally Posted by Galadriel55
I have not seen these quotes before, and I find them hard to reconcile with the rest of the philosophy of Middle-earth. I can understand Gandalf saying that Gandalf died, that Gandalf "was", implying that he is someone else - because he was indeed born anew, a reincarnation. But to imply that the fea was changed in the process - that I find hard to imagine. Things don't get re-created in Middle-earth because they failed to meet expectations or proved to be a disappointment, not in their essence. This idea goes against what feels right, Tolkien's own words or no. I just can't wrap my head around this. How do you picture this yourself? How do you reconcile this idea with everything else? I am willing to be persuaded but it needs persuasion.
|
I dont pretend to know all of Tolkien's thoughts and understandings, only what he has written. I would recommend reading his letters
https://www.amazon.com/Letters-J-R-R.../dp/0618056998
many of them are just the kind of answers you seek. People ask questions or point out supposed contradictions and he gives them the answer and understanding.
But i also i dont think Gandalf totally changed as in a new creation wholly. Tolkien said
"Of course he remains similar in personality and idiosyncrasy"
He did not go into much more detail so it is guess work from here. Gandalf the grey truly died we know that, and Gandalf the white was an upgrade version perhaps would be best way of understanding it.