Posted by Emrys:
Quote:
|
A greater difference is that I have chosen to delete any references which shows that Hurin doesn't know of the death of Glaurung cause for sure, in both versions, he as already visited Brethil. I think that the sentence was inteded to be inserted in a previous version in which Hurin visited brethil after Nargothrond.
|
True, but as the text stands it is already in the text denied that Húrin could think Glaurung would be still alive. So what we have here is just a thinking on paper, which clears things upfor the reader.
But it is a just critique of our editing and would like to here other about that point.
But what do you think of the passage from about Húrin as an admirer of Felagund?
Respectfully
Findegil