Quote:
Frankly, "inherent weakness in the Dark Elves" is not something I'm prepared to allow any credence.
|
Why? The Calaquendi are greatly increased in power and abilities by their association with the valar.
Quote:
Besides, that version seems highly confused as to where Dark Elves end and Sindar begin.
|
I think you are confusing Eldar with the elves of the light; the first are those who set out on the march; the second are those who actually saw the light of the Trees; the sindar are, therefore, of the elves of darkness, with Thingol the exception.