what happen if numenor didnt rebel against the valar?

[tom the eldest]

Now this a hypothetical theory about what happen if numenor do not fall to sauron sway and betray the valar.feel free to share your theory.

What happen if the scenario above happened?will the numenorean expel sauron from numenor?will they imprisoned him?what tactics will sauron use if the numenorean dont fall?could sauron rise at the time of isildur be prevented?fell free to answer!

[Zigûr]

It's worth remembering that the shadow fell upon Númenor long before Sauron was ever brought there. He was responsible for the Melkor-religion and the nadir of Númenor's darkness, but only because he exacerbated and took advantage of a long history of increasing faithlessness which had begun during the reign of Tar-Ciryatan over a thousand years earlier. They had forsaken the Valar long before Sauron ever arrived.

So we can look at it two ways:
a) what if the Númenóreans had never fallen to the shadow whatsoever?
b) what if Ar-Pharazôn had refused the counsel of Sauron?

Regarding a) I think that there would have been inevitable war for mastery of Middle-earth between Sauron and an alliance of the Noldor and the Númenóreans. Gil-Galad had foreseen the need for this as early as the reign of Tar-Meneldur. Tar-Minastir came to the aid of Gil-Galad. His son was Tar-Ciryatan. Perhaps if the shadow had not fallen, Ciryatan would have followed his father's example and established close ties with the Eldar. That being said, it was under the shadow that Númenor grew from a strong nation to a military and imperialist superpower, so a war between such opponents might have also been far more bitterly fought than, say, Ar-Pharazôn's bloodless rout of Sauron's hosts at Umbar.

As for b) I don't think it would have mattered much. Sauron had the One Ring with him, and I fear that his domination of the hearts and minds of the Númenóreans at that stage was largely inevitable.

[Belegorn]

Zigûr is right. The Númenóreans were already divided into two Parties before Sauron came. Those who were friendly with the Elves & revered the Valar, and those who were not and both Parties envied the Elve's Doom. This crystallized during the reign of the 14th King of Númenor.

"the greater party... called the King's Men, and they grew proud and were estranged from the Eldar and the Valar... the lesser party... called the Elendili, the Elf-friends; for though they remained loyal indeed to the King and the House of Elros, they wished to keep the friendship of the Eldar, and they hearkened to the counsel of the Lords of the West...they, ... did not wholly escape from the affliction of their people, and they were troubled by the thought of death." [Sil, Akallabêth, p. 328]

This ate at them badly. They really wanted to be as Elves and regretted their forefather's decision to be a Man. Sauron only played on this motivation of the Númenóreans and used it to aid in their downfall. It was really the only way he could beat them. He knew his armies stood no chance against them and when he saw the armies of the High-Men he realized they were even greater than the tales of their majesty. Imagine that! So Sauron did what he did best, he worked his magic in ways to get them to destroy themselves.

There was an attempt to get things to rights by the 2nd to last King of Númenor but the damage was already done and most of the people did not agree with the King anyway and repentance was not accepted by the Valar. He gave the Faithful a blow while he was around but otherwise they were always persecuted by the Kings Men and forbidden to engage with Elves or to speak their language.

They did themselves in and Sauron helped to speed it up.

[Belegorn]

Oh yea I forget, in the end the situation would probably have just been the same since they were already doing what they were in the habit of doing and Ar-Pharazôn would have still gone out to show Sauron who was the real big man on the block. He was like his father, eager for wealth and power and often went to M-E to subjugate lesser Men.

[tom the eldest]

The numenorean did have a history of faithlesness,but sauron is the final push it needed.and also,tar-palantir,the second last king of numenor,he tries to correct the numenorean to the right way.his daughter,miriel,would have continued her fatjer traditions,but ar-pharazon usurped he throne and become king.and its worth noting that ar-pharazon ,in his childhood,was friendly to the elves but was forced to folow his father beliefs.so,if ar-pharazon didnt follow his father,then the akkalabeth could be prevented,and many event in midle earth could be prevented.although it will have some consequences:men will never know hobbit,there will be no arnor and gondor,and theres none will contain the hordes of easterling and haradrim from entering midle-earth upon sauron will.sure the numenorean aretough,but mordor orcs,combined with the elite army of the easterling,the chariots of the balcoth,the horsemen of the variags,and the archer and mumakil of the haradrim is a devastating combo,even against the numenorean and the elves.

[Belegorn]

Originally Posted by tom the eldest

sure the numenorean aretough,but mordor orcs,combined with the elite army of the easterling,the chariots of the balcoth,the horsemen of the variags,and the archer and mumakil of the haradrim is a devastating combo,even against the numenorean and the elves.

Not that I'm putting down the abilities of these other Men, but it is said the Dúnedain, "became mighty in crafts, so that if they had had the mind they could easily have surpassed the evil kings of Middle-earth in the making of war and the forging of weapons; but they were become men of peace." [Sil, Akallabêth, p. 323] Not that it would have been an easy fight, but even Sauron dared not fight them in battle since, "he perceived that the power and majesty of the Kings of the Sea surpassed all rumour of them, so that he could not trust even the greatest of his servants to withstand them" [p. 334].

[Faramir Jones]

Originally Posted by tom the eldest

and its worth noting that ar-pharazon ,in his childhood,was friendly to the elves but was forced to folow his father beliefs.

Are you sure about that, tom? What I've read of him indicates that he was just as bad an elf and Valar hater as his father and grandfather.

Perhaps I've missed out something somewhere. Do you have the reference handy?

[tom the eldest]

Originally Posted by Faramir Jones

Are you sure about that, tom? What I've read of him indicates that he was just as bad an elf and Valar hater as his father and grandfather.

Perhaps I've missed out something somewhere. Do you have the reference handy?

I just read in the tolkien gateway that he and amandil were friends.trough amandil,ar-pharazon maybe originally friendly to elves,but he then follow his father footsteps and become on of the kings men

[Zigûr]

Originally Posted by tom the eldest

sure the numenorean aretough,but mordor orcs,combined with the elite army of the easterling,the chariots of the balcoth,the horsemen of the variags,and the archer and mumakil of the haradrim is a devastating combo,even against the numenorean and the elves.

That's assuming a great deal about the quality of the Men under Sauron's control. We know that they "grew strong in those days and built many towns and walls of stone, and they were numerous and fierce in war and armed with iron" but that mostly proves that they achieved a level of military and technological competence which hardly seems "elite". Similarly the forces described here are characteristic of Rhûn and Harad in the Third Age. We know much less about what constituted their armies in the Second. As Belegorn has pointed out, even in their days of peace the Númenóreans had the capacity to be formidable in war. I would argue that their victory would not be assured, however, because Númenor was only militarily unstoppable (by Sauron) during the time of the shadow, not in the earlier years.
My point is, however, that in my opinion the most likely event in any "Faithful Númenor" scenario seems to be to be a war for the "soul" of Middle-earth, as it were, not unlike the War of the Last Alliance and the War of the Ring, perhaps, but on a vaster scale and potentially far more catastrophic. Given that Sauron's greatest problem at the end of the Second Age was that Gil-Galad had managed to rebuild his military strength during the years of Sauron's absence in Númenor, an earlier war against the Noldor which did not give them recovery time and against a not fully militarised Númenor might have simply resulted in an inconclusive struggle which wore down both sides.

Originally Posted by tom the eldest

I just read in the tolkien gateway that he and amandil were friends.trough amandil,ar-pharazon maybe originally friendly to elves,but he then follow his father footsteps and become on of the kings men

He was Amandil's friend, but there's no evidence that he was ever anything other than envious and hateful of the Elves, just like the rest of his faction in Númenórean society.
The example of Tar-Palantír shows that it was, for the majority, "too late" for redemption even before the reign of Pharazôn.

[tom the eldest]

Ok then,zigur.i agree to you.
now,back to the topic.if ar-pharazon resist sauron and banish him to mordor,sauron could rebuild his troops in secrets,since the king will thought that sauron is defeated,he will not shows up anymore,while in reality sauron device another plan to weaken the numenorean.probably a surprise attack to umbar,and sauron impose much scarier image to his men,the former should take the numenorean by surprise,and the latter will make sauron army much more fearful to sauron thean to the numenorian.but the numenorian had ally.gil-galad and durin the third is still in middle earth,and they would prove to be hard to defeat.now,if this happen,then gil-galad wont be dead,no gollum,no iron hills or erebor,and the noldor would be still a very srong kingdom,unlike the waning elven sanctuary in the third age.