Tol-in-Gaurhoth XIII: Enter Shamville - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Firefoot · 11-11-2005, 06:30 AM

I don't really care whether we do a double lynching or not. But I do have to vote soon, so if a clear decision has not been reached I will vote for Glirdan so that we're not penned in one way or the other (as someone could still vote for Wayne).

Wilwa - obviously, I haven't seen your reasoning yet, but if those are the two you're debating between I would go for Eonwe unless you really do have a good reason for dreaming of Kitanna. Kitanna seems very innocent to me right now.

So if we take Wilwa's claim as true (I am starting to trust her more), then the three wolves must come from this list:

Celuien - She isn't wholly innocent in my eyes, but she is less suspicious than about four or five other people.
Eonwe - I'm pretty suspicious of him. A seer dream here might not be a bad idea.
Glirdan - Hm... I'm really not sure. He could be guilty, but now that I'm actually awake and thinking, I'm not seeing him as so guilty any more. My opinion of him flip-flops about as fast as he does. If we decide not to lynch him, a seer dream here would probably be effective.
Kitanna - I think she's probably innocent. Her analyses have all seemed straight-forward and honest to me.
Lalaith - Right now I think she may be innocent. However, a closer look at her posts might not be a bad idea.
LMP - I honestly do not feel very suspicious of him. Not to say that he isn't a superb bluffer, but at this point I think he is innocent.
Tar - 50-50. Sometimes her posts seem innocent; othertimes, guilty. She could bear a closer look.
Wayne - will be lynched; presumably is a wolf.

One of the things I would like to do is look more at possible trios - this will be easier once we know Wayne's (and Glirdan's?) roles.

I really wish I could have done something more in depth, but hopefully if this is the last chance I ever get to post, you all will know where I was going.

11-11-2005, 06:30 AM	#11
Firefoot Illusionary Holbytla Join Date: Dec 2003 Posts: 7,547	I don't really care whether we do a double lynching or not. But I do have to vote soon, so if a clear decision has not been reached I will vote for Glirdan so that we're not penned in one way or the other (as someone could still vote for Wayne). Wilwa - obviously, I haven't seen your reasoning yet, but if those are the two you're debating between I would go for Eonwe unless you really do have a good reason for dreaming of Kitanna. Kitanna seems very innocent to me right now. So if we take Wilwa's claim as true (I am starting to trust her more), then the three wolves must come from this list: Celuien - She isn't wholly innocent in my eyes, but she is less suspicious than about four or five other people. Eonwe - I'm pretty suspicious of him. A seer dream here might not be a bad idea. Glirdan - Hm... I'm really not sure. He could be guilty, but now that I'm actually awake and thinking, I'm not seeing him as so guilty any more. My opinion of him flip-flops about as fast as he does. If we decide not to lynch him, a seer dream here would probably be effective. Kitanna - I think she's probably innocent. Her analyses have all seemed straight-forward and honest to me. Lalaith - Right now I think she may be innocent. However, a closer look at her posts might not be a bad idea. LMP - I honestly do not feel very suspicious of him. Not to say that he isn't a superb bluffer, but at this point I think he is innocent. Tar - 50-50. Sometimes her posts seem innocent; othertimes, guilty. She could bear a closer look. Wayne - will be lynched; presumably is a wolf. One of the things I would like to do is look more at possible trios - this will be easier once we know Wayne's (and Glirdan's?) roles. I really wish I could have done something more in depth, but hopefully if this is the last chance I ever get to post, you all will know where I was going.