WWJ III - Nan Qualinmerë: Death Wish Valley

[Kath]

I suspect her due to her voting record and her knowingly targeting an innocent villager.

Knowingly targeting an innocent villager? Knowingly? Which innocent would this be Garin, how would she know unless she were a wolf, which as you say yourself she cannot be certain of. And anyway, she isn't the only one. Many others, including you yourself, did so. It was widely believed yesterday that Shelob was guilty, because of the way she was acting. Get yourself out of this snit Garin, or it looks like you'll find yourself going the same way.