Tol-in-Gaurhoth XLIX - At the Source of Darkness

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Eonwe

I say "Aim for a wolf and if you miss, you'll probably hit a cobbler."

Indeed.

And I see that we really need to settle this quote, Nog.

They saw each other, though the vision was too blurry and dark to reveal a thing.

All right- let's talk this through.

I go down to the docks to watch for someone on a boat. It's very foggy.

I see a boat arrive. I see someone on the boat.

Question- does that mean I can identify the person? Pick their face out of a line-up?

Nope.

Seeing someone does not equate with recognizing someone.

The narrative says that not a thing was revealed. I would assume that identities would be included in that. They merely saw each other in the sense that they saw that there were other Cobblers present.