Aragorn's Elfstone

[doug*platypus]

Lostgariel is quite right in thinking that a lot of answers can be found in the old mythologies that Tolkien loved, and was trying to resurrect an appreciation for. Just another reason to read some of these old stories - problem is, there are so many other great books to read that are easier to find.

As for Earendil's stone being Aragorn's, I admit that it's possible. But he'd have to be a pretty good shot to throw it down from where he is flying his magic ship through the upper airs, or Venus or wherever he's supposed to be. If the Istari bring it with them from the west, I don't think any mention is made of it.

EDIT: okay, so there is mention of it (Unfinished Tales). Out of the two possible theories, though, I think that it is the least likely. Anyone know which was the final, definitive version?

[ January 05, 2003: Message edited by: doug*platypus ]