Was the cast of characters perfect?

[Lomelinde]

Hee, hee, KingCarlton, those were great ideas(but Rosie o'Donnell as Arwen?). As I was reading those, I was imagining how those actors would deliver their lines in the movie and just about fell off my chair laughing. Especially Bette Midler and David Spade...I can just see it now- "You have entered the Realm of the Freaks, you cannot go back." Robin Williams definitely needs a role somewhere (maybe as a Balrog....or not. ) Ah yes, Tolkien is rolling over in his grave right now (as he has probably done many times lately ). But seriously, I thought the cast in the movie was great and with little fault. PJ did a good job!