How did you imagine things in the books?

[elle]

I agree with above, Haldir was the way I pictured him in the books. Craig did a great job. I also thoght the Golden Hall should of been better, it did look like a barn! And what about the Entdraut? and I thought Gollum was different in the movies than in the books, in my opinion. Lorien was dark, and I always thought of more trees, where are all the trees? And Rivendell, well I thought it was not so pretty, I mean it looked more like how Lorien should be! Also Aragorn was different, I thought of him older, and with a hat. He should have a hat, who agrees?