Most Tragic Figure

[zifnab]

Great thread to be brought back from the dead, over a year old! This one sure beats the current ones, “Who’s your Favorite” and “Who would you take home for summer vacation”. Is there a “Marriage” one out yet? [img]smilies/rolleyes.gif[/img]

I think you guys pretty much covered the majority of them. Good list Mho, I don’t totally agree on the order, but is covers a great deal. I would definitely put the “House of Hador” as my top pick, that covers all of Hurin, Huor and company. In my opinion, if you included Boromor and Gollum, shouldn’t you also include some characters like:

Beleg Cúthalion
Mîm the “petty” dwarf
Aredhel
Faramir

I won’t go into detail about what “tragedy” I think befall these characters but if Boromor and Gollum are on the list, then shouldn’t these be too?