If you could have.....

[Elianna]

Imrahil, because I don't think he was in the movie

I did see the silver swan on a blue field at Aragorn's coronation: from Aragorn's pov, to the right, behind Éowyn and Faramir. I was so happy when I saw it. I think Pete does it on purpose, makes the movies with some huge departures from the book so when we see something that should've been there all along, we're thrilled.

I think I really would've liked being Random Elf Chic #2 (if I couldn't be Éowyn): she's the one behind Arwen's left shoulder when the Fellowship is leaving Rivendell. See, then I'd get to meet most every main actor/actress person and be on the Rivendell set! Then I could look around New Zealand and go home, and not be stuck there 15 months.

[dkhyrosha]

As long as I was an elf, I would be happy. Legolas would be hard (concidering I'm a girl) but I could be an extra elf (under all that armor, I don't think anyone could tell I wasn't a boy)

but I wouldn't want to die either

[The Saucepan Man]

... but I could be an extra elf (under all that armor, I don't think anyone could tell I wasn't a boy)

Indeed, it might be a positive advantage given the "Chorus Line" which turned up at Helm's Deep.