Tol-in-Gaurhoth III (The Saga Continues...)

[the phantom]

Feeling that this comment is directed at me

You weren't the only one, so don't take the entire weight of my comments upon yourself. There are those you should share it with.

My main suspicion was based on you notorious flip-flop with your reasoning given.

Then why did you not mention it even once on the day you lynched me?

You asked why I did it on day one and I explained my reasoning, and I considered it pretty much burried after that. Plus, why would you be more suspicious of someone who had reversed positions on a seer-killing plan more than someone who had written a seer-killing plan? If that day one plan was you big concern, you definitely should've been gunning for Fordim.

But since you didn't mention it on day three I don't see how it was a factor.

However, I can see how someone looking back trying to justify their vote could think "Hmm, well... I must've suspected him because of that day one flip-flop. Yeah- that must've been it" when actually you weren't thinking about that at the time I was lynched.

I'm not sure if that is the case with you or not. Either way, it seems odd that my reaction to the plan was never mentioned if it was indeed the primary reason for your vote.

Also you have stated that votes are solid evidence so why not look at the fact that you voted for two innocents whether your vote was "forced" or not.

The fact that it was forced is what makes all the difference!

If there is no choice involved then there can be no guilt assigned.