Tol-in-Gaurhoth VII (The Saga goes ever on and on)

[The Only Real Estel]

Posted by Lhuna:

And there's this weird - extremely defensive, if I may say so - reply from Estel on post #322 on something mormegil said on post #321.

Posted by me:

Great. Thanks. Unless you are a werewolf you've just set me up for a perfect setup.

There seems to be an unfortunate attitude in this game that if someone seems innocent he must be guilty. While that can be true sometimes there is usually some shred of irrefutable evidence that can be found. But suspicions will be suspicions, & I do not hold yours against you.

I don't see anything too defensive about that. I made a valid point about the setup but apparently the wolves had other plans for that NIGHT. And the other point about 'if someone seems innocent he must be guilty' was being played out right before our eyes.

Plus, lmp was the first one to cast suspicion on Estel (and Eomer, not that it matters anymore)...and he died the Night after. The werewolf thought he had the Seer.

And he/she didn't. And yet we still take lmp's word as he was a seer? Oh well. Anyway, it was pretty obvious that lmp had his telescope pointing at the wrong constellation the last DAY he was around. He made all sorts of wierd/wolvish comments - I've said before that I was going to vote for him that DAY.

Anyways, it doesn't appear too many people took Lhuna too seriously. She's either trying to cause confusion by switching tracks (therefore she's the Cobbler), or she's the wolf & acting very wolfish.

edit: anyway, thanks to wilwa the majority has spoken & we'll probably find out soon enough