Welcome to Tol-in-Gauroth XI 'Fall of the Fall'

[The Saucepan Man]

Originally Posted by Perky

Sorry if I sound idiotic and foolish, Saucy, but what would you like to know?

A response to this would be nice:

Originally Posted by me

Perky, I find it hard to square these two comments of yours:

Quote:
Originally Posted by The Perky Ent
If no one has anywhere else to turn, I myself would be intrigued in Alcarillo's defence from Gil-Galad's acusations.

Quote:
Originally Posted by The Perky Ent
Once again, Gil shows poor reasoning for acusing Alcarillo of being a werewolf.

I would prefer to avoid cutting off my pipeweed supply, so I would welcome some sort of an explanation ...

[The Perky Ent]

Maybe I do need that deprogrammer!

Originally Posted by The Perky Ent
If no one has anywhere else to turn, I myself would be intrigued in Alcarillo's defence from Gil-Galad's acusations.

It appears that I had scanned past Alcarillo's post, or had forgetten it's existance. I apologize for confusing you, since I believe he already defended it.

Once again, Gil shows poor reasoning for acusing Alcarillo of being a werewolf.

I would prefer to avoid cutting off my pipeweed supply, so I would welcome some sort of an explanation ...

What I meant by that, which I think I had explained earlier, was that his acusation was out of the blue, and didn't have any real facts behind it. It wasn't something like "Johnny the Balrog should be lynched! He keeps giving off hints about fur and claws and himself being a wolf! He's a werewolf! lynch him!" There was no real evidence that could be proven against him. I hope these are satisfactory answers, as I am not the wordsmyth I once was (or never was ).

[The Saucepan Man]

That's all very well, Perky. But I still don't get how you can square backing up Gil's accusation with later using it as a basis for voting for Gil. You accused Gil of making a baseless accusation, and yet it was just as baseless when you earlier judged it sufficiently meritorious as to require an explanation from Alcarillo.