Welcome to Tol-in-Gauroth XI 'Fall of the Fall'

[Cailín]

Poor Shelob! She was indeed a logical choice for the wolves, cause she suspected few and was suspected by pretty much no one. Her suspects other than Gil-Galad were Mormegil (though it seemed she had changed her mind about him before the end of the day) and The Perky Ent, which does not tell us much except that I feel slightly more inclined to believe in the innocence of both.

Perky, it seems, is still high on many people’s suspect list – but I’m not sure about him. He seems too obvious to be a wolf. His vote for Gil did not seem very strange or suspicious to me yesterday – for I think he voiced suspicions of Gil before either one of them was clearly in the lead. Though I was sad to find out Gil was innocent, I don’t think we should regret our choice too much – undoubtedly we would have had to lynch him sooner or later I'm aware The Perky Ent is still someone who will get votes today, and he might very well deserve them, but I don't think his death would tell us much, except how terribly wrong we all were. But I'm really not sure about that.

Arcticstorm is also someone I’m still keeping a close eye on. His reasoning is flawed indeed, and though being illogical is not necessarily a wolfish trait, I think he bears watching.

SpM, yesterday you said some things concerning Eomer and I’m slightly disappointed you did not repeat them today. I did see some sense in your accusations.

Eomer of the Rohirrim comes to mind. After I pointed out that Formendacil’s early vote met my criteria for distrust (but signified that I was disinclined to vote for him to-Day), he made an accusation of Formendacil, which he later backtracked on.

This was strange indeed. After getting little support for his Formendacil-is-evil campaign, he pretended to have changed his mind and admitted he ‘fell’ for Formendacil’s strategy (what – was Formendacil trying to get himself killed?) and then tried to start a bandwagon against those with empty posts, namely Wilwarin and Azaelia. I think he expected more people to vote for Azaelia, because there were some (including me) who indeed found their absense not helpful and even suspicious.

Eomer concerns me in particular since, even though I was antagonistic towards him, he avoided rising to the bait.

Another thing that worries me. He seems very much in control of himself and there’s a definite tactical thoughtfulness in each of his posts.

Because of this, I could also make a slight case against Boromir88, but just a slight one.

Originally Posted by Saucepan Man (to me)

Well, I fully acknowledge that my reasoning may be awry. But how do you know it is?

I did not intend to say your reasoning was awry. I apologize, I sometimes say things that mean something entirely different than what I want them to. I really only pretend to speak English. I meant your reasoning seemed to be purely that – reasoning – without any knowledge others may not have. As you always tend to do. I don’t know if that’s just being very clever, or you’re truly what you seem to be.

There's still many of you we have not heard from today, so I'm still waiting for more things to go on. I'd like a reaction from Eomer to this, though.