The Silmarillion Survivor

[Formendacil]

By the laws of inheritance, the eldest son/child (in this case the same thing) of the previous High King inherits. With Finwe dead, it goes to Feanor. With Feanor dead, it goes to Maedhros, so:

++Maedhros, High King of the Noldor

and, since inheritance is the issue of the day, I say we remove old Nolofinwe. He's well-known to have pretensions towards his nephew's throne, and chafes under the rule of someone younger.

++Finwe-Nolofinwe Finwion, for removal from the island.

Terribly sorry, Anguirel et al, if my voting seems more stale this time around, but the new nature of these challenges and such makes things quite a bit less random than before...