What happened at Mount Doom?

[Formendacil]

Originally Posted by davem

I meant Gollum - if Eru was responsible for him 'tripping'...

That begs the question then, of whether Eru is to be considered a murderer for killing off his own creatures- made by Him, and Him alone, and subject to his will. If one thinks of the fate of Ar-Pharazon and his men as "murder", then he's guilty.

For that matter, if the very fact that he made Men (and Hobbits) mortal- thus killing even the healthiest of them in the end, is murder, then we have a major killer here...

But I would contend that IF Eru "fated" Gollum to trip, that does not mean that he killed him. As far as fate goes, if Gollum was fated to trip, then Frodo was fated to go to Valinor, Isildur was fated to lose the Ring and die, and Turin was fated to kill himself.

I don't personally think that Eru "pushed" Gollum (ie. Murdered him), but I do sense His hand in it...