TOL-IN-GAURHOTH XII, Erbar Telamarth

[mormegil]

I'm starting to think about the Boro/Encai and while I've been highly suspicious of Encai since nearly the beginning I'm wondering now if Boromir used the ploy of pretending to be seer to have us believe him on this day. The reason being if we believe he is genuine (which he could be but I'm viewing it now as he is not) then we think him innocent because he tried to protect the seer. However if Encai had been a wolf then she would have picked up on that and killed him last night...right???? I'm notorious for my crazy ideas and theories so I guess what I'm saying is that it seems to be a waste to vote for both. I would rather see Feanor or TGWBS and one of the Boromir/Encai duo.

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Let's not kill me, hm? I promise that's not a cool idea.

Morm... what changed your mind from "I think Fea was framed" to "let's kill her anyways"?

[mormegil]

Yes Fea but still something isn't sitting right and you're our resident enigma and finding out for sure would clear up some air.

I thought that I already answered this question Fea. Your simply such an unknown factor and lately you seem oddly sincere and as you stated if we believe you to be innocent that's when we should lynch you But there is still the chance that we choose TGWBS.

I just want everybody to know how horribly confused I am right now and I must say that I am glad Lhuna is gone because to add one more in the mix would probably send in mental overload and fry my feeble brain.

[Encaitare]

It's taken me a bit to read through all the posts and I have to go out again in about 5 minutes. So just a couple of things I'd like to throw out there...

1. I had no idea Formen was a wolf -- I thought he might be the Seer, since he voted for Underhill twice when there was really little suspicion cast on him otherwise. I alluded to this idea in a couple of other posts when I said that Formen's voting was interesting and we might want to watch it closely. Obviously I was wrong about that one.

2. Fea wonders why I saved her. For the record, I didn't "save" her at all. There's nothing to be curious about. I merely thought that Shelob was more suspicious than Fea. I always end up voting late due to my time zone.

3.

Originally Posted by morm

I'm wondering now if Boromir used the ploy of pretending to be seer to have us believe him on this day.

This was tied into the theory I had going in point 1. I thought that since Formen might be the Seer, Boromir couldn't be, and that he was a wolf pretending to be.

I have to go tutor now; I'll be back in 2 hours or so (7 PM EST). I hope you all vote wisely toDay.