Tol-in-Gaurhoth Dream Team - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Boromir88 · 10-27-2005, 08:26 AM

Ok, with the recent Werewolf game over, here's a new dream team that I've sort of conjured up...

Wolves

Estelyn- If she was the last wolf, I would have shot myself in the foot. She played great in her first game, and I was definitely worried that she had pulled the curtains over our eyes and was the last wolf. (Though Enca was my first suspect)

tgwbs- Another one that would be a dangerous wolf. The whole game he went through relatively unsuspected and his "analytical" posts keeps suspicion off him.

Cailin- Honestly, if Eomer didn't find her, I don't know how long I would have went without suspecting her as a wolf. She just doesn't come off as being a wolf, which makes her of course more dangerous.

Black Beorning

Feanor- She kind of comes off as this loner. She can get along just fine by herself, and no matter how suspicious she is, people just can't pull the trigger on her (or the rope?). She'd be a scary bear.

Seer

mormegil- simply because I believed he was the Seer. He seems to be a good judge of character, on who to trust, who to not, who to go after, who to defend, and still stay away from the wolves claws.

Hunter

Eomer- Just kind of tipping my hat to him again (or sucking up whatever you prefer). For spotting something and finding Cailin the 2nd night.

Ranger

Firefoot- another good innocent to have. Is able to look at posts and find who's a wolf and who isn't.

Cobbler

Mr. Underhill- Don't know why, just seems he could make a good cobbler. I'm just interested in seeing him play this role.

Innocents

Shelob- Too bad she always seems to die early, either by wolves, or by villagers. I think she could add a lot to the village.

Spawn- again, every village needs someone like Spawn to analyze posts and hunt down the wolves.

Gil- again, everyone needs one.

lmp- sad he too had to die early, he makes a good asset for the villagers.

Formendacil- Another fun player, I just liked picking on him the last game

Mithalwen- She didn't make a very good wolf in the first game I played, perhaps this means she's not a "bad" person.

But, I'm itching to get in another game with this lady, and perhaps she'll make a better innocent little by-standard, then a wolf?

Sauce- another one no village can be without. A scary, scary, person for the wolves as he's always able to find them. And I was just so delirious in thinking he was in the last game.

Mithalwen · 10-27-2005, 10:54 AM

[QUOTE=Boromir88]

Mithalwen- She didn't make a very good wolf in the first game I played, perhaps this means she's not a "bad" person.

But, I'm itching to get in another game with this lady, and perhaps she'll make a better innocent little by-standard, then a wolf?

QUOTE]

I was a good innocent in game one - I picked 2 wolves straight off ... and even when I was a wolf I picked the Bear instantly.. I wouldn't say I am a particularly good person but I find it virtually impossible to lie under any circumstances. So being a wolf was peculiarly stressfull and means I am unlikely to play again.

the phantom · 10-27-2005, 11:39 AM

Quote:

I find it virtually impossible to lie under any circumstances. So being a wolf was peculiarly stressfull

Then don't lie when you're a wolf, Mith.

When you read my posts in Werewolf X (I was a wolf in that game) you will find that I barely lied at all.

The key is to tell truths that don't lead to the truth.

Bêthberry · 10-27-2005, 12:51 PM

Just to remind you all of Estelyn's post #16 here, 10-10-2005:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Estelyn Telcontar

Why on earth is everyone thinking I'd be so foolish as to disregard RL considerations (to say nothing of the fast-paced RPG I'm leading ) and join a game just when I'm about to answer an invitation negatively?!

Not to be confused with her first post (#14) on the phantom's recently concluded game: posted on the 10-15-2005

Mithalwen · 10-28-2005, 02:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by the phantom

When you read my posts in Werewolf X (I was a wolf in that game) you will find that I barely lied at all.

When?

Phantom, sweetheart, this may be a kick in the Shire for your ego but I do not eagerly devour every word you write

. The mainstream WW games have become so Dickensian in length that I have stopped trying to follow them completely - I just dip in. I see the page number increase, and daunted, sigh and flip to crazy captions which suit my attention span better. The thoughts of Chairman Phantom are therefore not going to be top of my reading list. However, I did happen to glance at the aforementioned memoirs of a blood-hunting wolf before my essai at lycanthropy. So my failure is all your fault

......

the phantom · 10-28-2005, 02:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kate Beckinsale

but I do not eagerly devour every word you write

Well, I imagine most of your problems in life, Werewolf and other, can be attributed to that.

Such lack of interest in my words indicates a deep seated resentment of wisdom and demonstrates a lack of good taste.

Mithalwen · 10-28-2005, 02:32 PM

Oh get over you

the phantom · 10-28-2005, 02:42 PM

Oh, I've tried, I really have- but no matter how hard I try I just can't wish away my feelings for myself. That's part of being in love.

Not to mention, if I succeeded in "getting over myself", I wouldn't be the phantom anymore. That's like asking Tom Bombadil to stop singing silly songs.

And, while I am here, I thought I'd mention that my Dream Team village in WW XII lived up to my expectations. I really did enjoy watching the action each day. Great performances all around- worthy of Dream Team consideration from top to bottom.

Firefoot · 10-28-2005, 03:10 PM

Here goes:

Mod: phantom - Need I say more? It's a close race between playing with him and having him mod, though...

Wolves:

Myself - If I could pick for myself a role this would be it. Ever since the first game *refuses to go off on a tangent* I've wanted to have another shot at this role. I can't say how good I'd be at it, but if voting records are any kind of indication I could last quite a while - apparently I'm not a terribly suspicious person, as I've never been lynched since WWI.

Fea - Fea has proven herself to be very good at this role, and besides, I'd rather have her on my side. For once I'd know what the heck she's playing at.

Besides, I think people have gotten to a point where they mostly suspect her for being her, rather than for reasons.

Oromin - She's a great quiet wolf to have around.

Seer: Boromir88 - now he'd be a powerful enemy. His performance in IIX was superb.

Ranger: Morm - he's a very astute player, I think he could play this role well. He may even make a save. (Am I the only one who's ever done that? I haven't paid much attention to the recent games.)

Hunter: Eomer - I think his performance in XII speaks for itself.

Cursed: Nilpaurion - I'd love to see him pull off that switch.

Others:

Saucepan - what's a game without SpM?
Fordim - I rather miss having him around. A great loudmouth, full of stretegies.
Kath - A game just doesn't seem quite complete without her.
Kitanna - Same as Kath. Another great backbone player
LMP - Another great player to have around...
TORE - If there was a cobbler, he'd be it, but otherwise a great player.
Esty - played brilliantly in XII.
Kuru - It's been too long since I've played in a game with him.
Gurthang - Another great player - and if I had a bear he'd be it.

There are definitely people I've left out here, sadly - I wish I could include about ten more. I also wish I knew more about some of the players who have only played in games IX and following, since I don't know anything about most of you except for some hearsay.

Feanor of the Peredhil · 10-28-2005, 03:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Firefoot

Fea - Fea has proven herself to be very good at this role, and besides, I'd rather have her on my side. For once I'd know what the heck she's playing at.

Besides, I think people have gotten to a point where they mostly suspect her for being her, rather than for reasons.

Actually, there's a good chance you still would have no idea what I was doing.

Unless Day PMs were allowed, in which case I'd keep you up to date with my most recent random plan of self-serving. Actually, I'm thinking I'd most prefer the role of Bear. I don't remember who gave me it, but boy would that be my favorite game. It very much appeals to my sense of the universe revolving around me. Not having to work with people... "If you want something done right, do it yourself." It would be a lark, casting suspicion on everyone, wolf and villager alike, and playing solely for my own amusement. Cough... wait... I think I might already do that. That's probably not good.

Quote:

He may even make a save. (Am I the only one who's ever done that? I haven't paid much attention to the recent games.)

I made one (almost two... *kicks self*) in Glirdy's WWJI.

My dream team... is still the same as it was before. Only I'd like to add Underhill to it as a wolf. I know I already have three wolves on my dream team... but we ended up with four in Mith's game. It could happen again. And I rather think he'd make an incredible bad guy.

10-27-2005, 10:54 AM	#2
Mithalwen Pilgrim Soul Join Date: May 2004 Location: watching the wonga-wonga birds circle... Posts: 9,461	[QUOTE=Boromir88] Mithalwen- She didn't make a very good wolf in the first game I played, perhaps this means she's not a "bad" person. But, I'm itching to get in another game with this lady, and perhaps she'll make a better innocent little by-standard, then a wolf? QUOTE] I was a good innocent in game one - I picked 2 wolves straight off ... and even when I was a wolf I picked the Bear instantly.. I wouldn't say I am a particularly good person but I find it virtually impossible to lie under any circumstances. So being a wolf was peculiarly stressfull and means I am unlikely to play again. __________________ “But Finrod walks with Finarfin his father beneath the trees in Eldamar.” Christopher Tolkien, Requiescat in pace

10-28-2005, 02:32 PM	#7
Mithalwen Pilgrim Soul Join Date: May 2004 Location: watching the wonga-wonga birds circle... Posts: 9,461	Think you're Mr Know-it-all? Oh get over you __________________ “But Finrod walks with Finarfin his father beneath the trees in Eldamar.” Christopher Tolkien, Requiescat in pace

10-28-2005, 02:42 PM	#8
the phantom Beloved Shadow Join Date: Jul 2002 Location: The Stadium Posts: 5,971	Oh, I've tried, I really have- but no matter how hard I try I just can't wish away my feelings for myself. That's part of being in love. Not to mention, if I succeeded in "getting over myself", I wouldn't be the phantom anymore. That's like asking Tom Bombadil to stop singing silly songs. And, while I am here, I thought I'd mention that my Dream Team village in WW XII lived up to my expectations. I really did enjoy watching the action each day. Great performances all around- worthy of Dream Team consideration from top to bottom. __________________ the phantom has posted. This thread is now important.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Switch to Linear Mode Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

10-27-2005, 08:26 AM	#1
Boromir88 Laconic Loreman Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: USA Posts: 7,521	Ok, with the recent Werewolf game over, here's a new dream team that I've sort of conjured up... Wolves Estelyn- If she was the last wolf, I would have shot myself in the foot. She played great in her first game, and I was definitely worried that she had pulled the curtains over our eyes and was the last wolf. (Though Enca was my first suspect) tgwbs- Another one that would be a dangerous wolf. The whole game he went through relatively unsuspected and his "analytical" posts keeps suspicion off him. Cailin- Honestly, if Eomer didn't find her, I don't know how long I would have went without suspecting her as a wolf. She just doesn't come off as being a wolf, which makes her of course more dangerous. Black Beorning Feanor- She kind of comes off as this loner. She can get along just fine by herself, and no matter how suspicious she is, people just can't pull the trigger on her (or the rope?). She'd be a scary bear. Seer mormegil- simply because I believed he was the Seer. He seems to be a good judge of character, on who to trust, who to not, who to go after, who to defend, and still stay away from the wolves claws. Hunter Eomer- Just kind of tipping my hat to him again (or sucking up whatever you prefer). For spotting something and finding Cailin the 2nd night. Ranger Firefoot- another good innocent to have. Is able to look at posts and find who's a wolf and who isn't. Cobbler Mr. Underhill- Don't know why, just seems he could make a good cobbler. I'm just interested in seeing him play this role. Innocents Shelob- Too bad she always seems to die early, either by wolves, or by villagers. I think she could add a lot to the village. Spawn- again, every village needs someone like Spawn to analyze posts and hunt down the wolves. Gil- again, everyone needs one. lmp- sad he too had to die early, he makes a good asset for the villagers. Formendacil- Another fun player, I just liked picking on him the last game Mithalwen- She didn't make a very good wolf in the first game I played, perhaps this means she's not a "bad" person. But, I'm itching to get in another game with this lady, and perhaps she'll make a better innocent little by-standard, then a wolf? Sauce- another one no village can be without. A scary, scary, person for the wolves as he's always able to find them. And I was just so delirious in thinking he was in the last game. __________________ Fenris Penguin

10-28-2005, 03:10 PM	#9
Firefoot Illusionary Holbytla Join Date: Dec 2003 Posts: 7,547	Here goes: Mod: phantom - Need I say more? It's a close race between playing with him and having him mod, though... Wolves: Myself - If I could pick for myself a role this would be it. Ever since the first game refuses to go off on a tangent I've wanted to have another shot at this role. I can't say how good I'd be at it, but if voting records are any kind of indication I could last quite a while - apparently I'm not a terribly suspicious person, as I've never been lynched since WWI. Fea - Fea has proven herself to be very good at this role, and besides, I'd rather have her on my side. For once I'd know what the heck she's playing at. Besides, I think people have gotten to a point where they mostly suspect her for being her, rather than for reasons. Oromin - She's a great quiet wolf to have around. Seer: Boromir88 - now he'd be a powerful enemy. His performance in IIX was superb. Ranger: Morm - he's a very astute player, I think he could play this role well. He may even make a save. (Am I the only one who's ever done that? I haven't paid much attention to the recent games.) Hunter: Eomer - I think his performance in XII speaks for itself. Cursed: Nilpaurion - I'd love to see him pull off that switch. Others: Saucepan - what's a game without SpM? Fordim - I rather miss having him around. A great loudmouth, full of stretegies. Kath - A game just doesn't seem quite complete without her. Kitanna - Same as Kath. Another great backbone player LMP - Another great player to have around... TORE - If there was a cobbler, he'd be it, but otherwise a great player. Esty - played brilliantly in XII. Kuru - It's been too long since I've played in a game with him. Gurthang - Another great player - and if I had a bear he'd be it. There are definitely people I've left out here, sadly - I wish I could include about ten more. I also wish I knew more about some of the players who have only played in games IX and following, since I don't know anything about most of you except for some hearsay.