Tol-in-Gaurhoth XIII: Enter Shamville

[wilwarin538]

there has to be more reason to it than just that I flip-flop around a lot

I personally think that should be reason enough.

**and actaully its more we can't say "back in WW2", we can say things like, "Oh his attitude is nothing new", as long as we don't directely refer to a past game its ok**

[Firefoot]

Okay, here's my analysis of Day 1, since I coudn't do it yesterday. It's probably not complete, as I was trying to gather general thoughts of everyone rather than target people. Also, I was getting lazy towards the end (I've been working on this for too long). Now at least I know who I'm primarily focusing on. I have read up on the Day 2 stuff, but not gone through it thoroughly. It does not contribute to this.

Anguirel
Suspects: Glirdan; Kath, Menel, Firefoot, Glirdan, Eonwe, Celuien; Wayne (for lack of posting)
Accuses:
Defends:
Votes: Wayne

General: Some back-and-forth with Lalaith at the start, encourages lots of talking; Disagrees with LMP’s plan; dislikes Wayne’s lack of substance and intends to vote for him for that reason. I find him rather suspicious. It’s mild suspicion, mostly because I haven’t found much to really back it up. But I’m definitely watching him.

Celuien
Suspects: (mildly Glirdan, Bergil, Wayne, tar-ancalime;
Accuses:
Defends:
Votes: Wayne

General: Early on, has seen nothing so far suspicious, brief summary of so far happenings; refuses to make random accusations; disagrees with LMP’s plan. She’s not too suspicious to me. I have followed what she has said, I haven’t seen anything to make me suspect her.

Eonwe
Suspects:
Accuses:
Defends:
Votes: Kath (randomly)

General: Wants everyone to explain their theories in depth; responds to Menel that the wolves would have to be very lazy to have to communicate publicly with other wolves during day; says random voting is pretty much the only way to go on Day 1, rating helpfulness is useless; thinks LMP’s plan is worthy, but doesn’t want to be leader; clarifies to say he doesn’t want to use the plan yet, but wait till later. He’s somewhere in the middle for me. I’d like to hear some more concrete suspicions from him.

Glirdan
Suspects: Celuien, Kath, tar-ancalime (apparently serious); LMP (later retracted), Eonwe, Bergil;
Accuses:
Defends:
Votes: Eonwe

General: Mostly jesting accusations of everyone, though with some serious thrown in; seems to suspect LMP not based on content of plan but because it is a plan – could be a wolf trying to influence events too much; now disagrees with LMP’s plan based on content. He is all over the place, and rather suspicious to me. I will gather opinions from toDay and make some judgments from that.

Kath
Suspects: Menel (past experiences); mildly: Ang, Glirdan, stronger: Kuru, LMP, Wilwa;
Accuses: Firefoot, Lalaith, Wilwa (randomly);
Defends:
Votes: Wilwa

General: Says that she’s talking just to generate discussion; briefly disagrees with LMP’s plan, doesn’t really state specific reasons; In depth analysis of everyone over two posts; wants to hear more from Wayne. She seems pretty innocent to me. I haven’t really seen anything to make me suspect her.

Kitanna
Suspects: Glirdan; Bergil, Glirdan (both mild); Anguirel, Lalaith, tar-ancalime, Wilwa, Eonwe, Celuien
Accuses:
Defends:
Votes: Celuien

General: Agrees that talking without substance doesn’t help the village, dislikes Kuru’s idea of random voting without discussion but otherwise agrees with him; wants reasoning from Bergil about his vote, disagrees with LMP’s plan, thinks Glirdan changes his mind too much. Again, I don’t have too much reason to suspect her. She seems pretty innocent to me.

Lalaith
Suspects: Glirdan, Bergil, Wayne, Wilwa, LMP, Firefoot, Menel, Ang, Kuru (in order)
Accuses:
Defends:
Votes: Bergil

General: Some back and forth with Ang at the start, wants everyone to talk as much as they can; explicitly states that she is not a wolf; is glad for LMP’s plan as it gives something to discuss; long analysis of everyone, though with few of her own comments; says it’s too easy to vote for Wayne. She’s in the middle for me. Not really suspicious, though not quite cleared. There are other candidates that I find more suspicious than her.

littlemanpoet Suspects: Glirdan; mildly: Kitanna (retracted), Bergil, tar-ancalime, stronger: Celuien, Lalaith, Wayne, Wilwa, Kath (retracted quickly);
Accuses:
Defends:
Votes: tar-ancalime

General: Agrees that talk with substance is necessary; suggests we elect leader; finds Eonwe’s assessment of his plan to be accurate; did not bring up plan fully conscious of flaws, wanted to generate discussion. He’s on my probably-innocent list right now. Though I disagreed with his plan, I can see the virtue in presenting a plan however flawed – they generate discussion. I’m not too concerned about him.

Meneltarmacil
Suspects: Lalaith; Lalaith, Kuru;
Accuses:
Defends:
Votes:

General: Suggests that Lalaith may be communicating with fellow wolves; disagrees with LMP’s plan. I’m not sure what to think about him. He’s in between.

tar-ancalime
Suspects: Ang, Bergil, Wayne
Accuses:
Defends:
Votes: Ang

General: In-character comments; doesn’t see any reason to use LMP’s plan, that it’s basically just a conscious band-wagon. I am somewhat suspicious of her. I’d like to hear more of substance.

WaynetheGoblin
Suspects: Glirdan, Bergil
Accuses:
Defends:
Votes: Bergil

General: Plain and simple, he’s brief and basically unhelpful. Definitely need to hear more from him, preferably something extensive.

Wilwarin538
Suspects: Wayne, Bergil
Accuses:
Defends:
Votes: Bergil

General: Jesting accusations of everyone, declares herself innocent; defends herself to Bergil. She is also in between. I have only mild suspicions of her.

Overall:
Suspicious:
Ang
Glirdan
Menel
Tar-ancalime
Wayne
Wilwa

In the middle:
Eonwe
Lalaith

Not too suspicious:
Celuien
Kath
Kitanna
LMP