Tol-in-Gaurhoth XIV: Nyárë Nauroron Númenoreva - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Aiwendil · 12-14-2005, 08:41 PM

It seems that while both the Wolves were fooled by Gurthang, all the innocents saw right through him - not that it did us much good.

I did wonder at times whether Formendacil might be a wolf, but the fact that he voted for Spawn before her death was inevitable but after I had voiced suspicion of her kept tripping me up. That seemed like something a wolf just wouldn't do, unless it was a deliberate sacrifice. It was a very daring move - and one that might have been disastrous if they hadn't happened to kill the Seer that night.

Holbytlass, on the other hand, I didn't suspect for a second. Her tactic of going against popular opinion and consistently attacking me worked perfectly.

And to put Lhuna's mind at rest - after thinking about it, I've concluded that the fact that she was unable to come forward and declare herself the Ranger before being lynched did not alter the result of the game. Had she done so, we would have killed Kath - but, finding her innocent, I would have hunted Lhuna that night, thus taking her out instead of Mormegil. So it still would have been 2 wolves, 2 innocents, and the cobbler the next day. So don't fret, Lhuna - and I'm glad to hear you're all right.

And I've forgotten to thank Alcarillio for doing such a great job. Using Numenor as the setting was a great idea.

Lhunardawen · 12-14-2005, 09:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aiwendil

And to put Lhuna's mind at rest - after thinking about it, I've concluded that the fact that she was unable to come forward and declare herself the Ranger before being lynched did not alter the result of the game. Had she done so, we would have killed Kath - but, finding her innocent, I would have hunted Lhuna that night, thus taking her out instead of Mormegil. So it still would have been 2 wolves, 2 innocents, and the cobbler the next day. So don't fret, Lhuna - and I'm glad to hear you're all right.

That's sad. I was afraid my first post after Jack's death made it to obvious that I was the Ranger...apparently it didn't. And I was fearing for my life every Night, but it turns out I should have been more afraid during the Day.

Where did I go wrong?

Oh, and thanks.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Switch to Linear Mode Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

12-14-2005, 08:41 PM	#1
Aiwendil Late Istar Join Date: Mar 2001 Posts: 2,224	It seems that while both the Wolves were fooled by Gurthang, all the innocents saw right through him - not that it did us much good. I did wonder at times whether Formendacil might be a wolf, but the fact that he voted for Spawn before her death was inevitable but after I had voiced suspicion of her kept tripping me up. That seemed like something a wolf just wouldn't do, unless it was a deliberate sacrifice. It was a very daring move - and one that might have been disastrous if they hadn't happened to kill the Seer that night. Holbytlass, on the other hand, I didn't suspect for a second. Her tactic of going against popular opinion and consistently attacking me worked perfectly. And to put Lhuna's mind at rest - after thinking about it, I've concluded that the fact that she was unable to come forward and declare herself the Ranger before being lynched did not alter the result of the game. Had she done so, we would have killed Kath - but, finding her innocent, I would have hunted Lhuna that night, thus taking her out instead of Mormegil. So it still would have been 2 wolves, 2 innocents, and the cobbler the next day. So don't fret, Lhuna - and I'm glad to hear you're all right. And I've forgotten to thank Alcarillio for doing such a great job. Using Numenor as the setting was a great idea.