Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVI: No man is an Island

[Gurthang]

Originally Posted by Garin

Now I hate to cross swords with Gurthang but he was willing to allow a tie, which would leave the deciding vote in the hands of lycans. In retrospect, this might have been a good tactic. Suspicion would be directed to the survivor, a potential wolf. Personally, I would rather die than let the wolves decide anything. They already had their feeding hour and basically slit their own throat. They are either idiots or devious. (Great insight, I know.)

Actually, the rules now state that the first villager to achieve the tying total will be lynched. I didn't realize that it had changed until after I had voted.

Originally Posted by Amanaduial

Well now, Alcarillo, if that ain't a suspiciously competitive attitude, I just don't know what is. Garin was accused of looking to the future, but Alcarillo goes a step further: he makes bold statements about the future, and, further than that, he assumes that the wolves will not be caught, and that he will not be caught, although whether those two statements are in fact one and the same, we are yet to find out. Competition? Would it not be better to work together to try to catch out the wolf, rather than viewing each other as 'competition' - for what, meat?! Maybe not - for a wolf!

Now this makes me suspicious, much more so than Alcarillo's comment that she was talking about. I think you read way to much into that little phrase. It would almost stand to reason that she had nailed your tactics and so you wanted to shoot her thoughts down.

Originally Posted by Nilpaurion

Nice going, Emily. 'You could only catch a werewolf if random chance.'

When did Emily show up? I've never heard out of her before...

Looks like Nilp beat me to an analysis of Kath; I still haven't had time to read through her posts. I'll probably still do it, but my analysis, if any at all, will be short.

So many people are doing little suspicious things, I'm finding it hard to even keep stuff straight. Right now: Garin, Eluchil, Valier(too agreeable and non-commital), Lhuna(early 'random' vote), and Cailín(largely due to other's comments which I find sensible). I've also been wondering about Nilp, but I doubt I'll vote for him toDay.