Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVI: No man is an Island

[Lhunardawen]

Originally Posted by Kuruharan

So I'm going to offer my tactical suggestion now. I think you are quite right to demand an answer from Amanaduial about her alleged Hunterness (I personally don't believe it). If she claims to be the Hunter, we have a problem of dueling Hunters. The only available option would be to kill one of them and order them, if they are in fact the Hunter, to kill the other.

It is a bit ruthless, I know, but when you have dueling Hunters it is really the only thing to do.

We also might want to consider killing Naria toDAY if things really become cloudy (i.e. Amanaduial denies being the Hunter and can plausibly explain things away). There is a chance (even though I believe her) that Naria is lying. If she is the Hunter we can tell her to pick her best target. However, I think this is only an option of last resort...

I'm a little wary of this. If they both turn out to be innocent, we'll be losing two innocents in a single blow. Plus another one during the Night...which could be me.

Last resort? Hmm...I guess we'll have to wait for Aman. Unfortunately, I can't.

(Oh, where is Gurthang when you need him... )

Okay, my guess is that Naria really is the Hunter. Otherwise, Aman could have instinctively jumped out and cried "Liar!" If Aman admits to being the Hunter, I guess we have no choice but to pursue the duel...but if she doesn't, I'm not yet too sure about lynching her.

I fear, somewhere deep inside, that this is yet another manipulative move to lynch an innocent. I'm very sorry Kuru, but I guess you can't blame me for being so suspicious. This isn't the first time something like this has happened.

Where is the double-lynching rule when you need it...

I'll be back for a vote, and then I must go.