WWJ III - Nan Qualinmerë: Death Wish Valley

[Gandalf_the _white]

oh no!!! I think the mistake that Shelob and Gorin made was actually stating that they were innocent this makes people believe that they are desperate to convince people that they were indeed innocent

[Gandalf_the _white]

without looking through the posts i think i've only voted once and that was because he found me suspicious for the smae reason as i found him

[Kath]

Ok then, lets look at those few posts we have by Wayne and Gandalf and see if we can glean anything from them.

Wayne:
Day 1:
Usual vague first post – regret over the killing of the mods, says he won’t leave til all the wolves are dead.
Votes for Fea saying it’s due to her ‘strange vote’ though we don’t know whether he was referring to her vote for Eomer or herself.

Day 2:
Actually some thought it seems, says the wolves wouldn’t vote for someone and then kill them the same Night. Odd sentence about meaning to vote for Lommy, when he’d already voted for Fea. Does a list (with no explanation) putting Gandalf at the top and himself at the bottom. Tar is second down and Fea third – could be (if her is a wolf) that there was some argument as to which would be killed that Night.

i dont trust anyone.i dont care what he said but i go by my gut.i wanted to change my vote and abrodcrobie sorry your before me. gandalf has been acting strange to strange and with all the things going on i will vote.

I challenge anyone to make sense of that! But followed up with a vote for Gandalf, perhaps in retaliation.

Day 3:
Oh hell, he wrote ordo in bolded letters. Wayne usually tells the truth with this so there actually seems no point in lynching him. He only went back and did this today though, so it could be to save his own skin. Still suspects Gandalf due to voting for those who vote for him.


Gandalf:
Day 1:
Nothing

Day 2:
Explains his absence from the Day before, no computer access and lack of knowledge that we had started.
Continually repeats this excuse, and states it as a reason for Wayne’s suspicion of him. Also makes a point of mentioning his newbie status – perhaps to stop us thinking he even could be a wolf.
Votes for Wayne, I think due to his lack of posting.

Day 3:
Worried about Valesse. Doesn’t want to bandwagon but is tempted to vote Garin anyway.
Repeats the lack of access excuse, claims not to know anything about werewolf games and repeats reasoning for voting for him.
No vote it seems.

Day 4:
Yet another mention of the reason for a lack of posting. Somehow decides living in England is another reason.
Refuses to explain why he’s innocent (though he wasn’t actually asked to do this) for fear it would make people see him as too defensive.

Now, to be completely honest I still want to lynch both of them. Wayne did put ordo in a past post, which means he was online today, but rather than make a post he simply went back and edited (something that is not actually allowed) which means I'm still suspicious of him. Gandalf I might give the benefit of the doubt too, but he has put just too much emphasis on his reasons for being away rather than being any help.

Also, if anyone could do an analysis of Mith that would be great.

My vote will likely to go Wayne soon.

[Gandalf_the _white]

i'm sorry i can't be of much help but due to my "newbie status" as you put it i don't spot things as easily as the rest of you and it usually takes someone posting it for me to notice it
I can see why suspicions are arroused about me and i must admit if i was in your shoes i'd be suspicious aswell

[Gandalf_the _white]

and the thing about being scared of valesse was harmless fun because she said she was dreaming of me

[Roa_Aoife]

Also, if anyone could do an analysis of Mith that would be great.

Coming right up! Anyone else want an analysis of a specific person while I'm at it?

[Roa_Aoife]

Mith Analysis
Day 1
First post is a safe post, as expected. Suspicious of Eomer. Works with Valesse in pointing suspicion at Fea and Valier (seems to be a simple farce) Suggests choosing Fea. First insulted by Eomer’s suggestion of confusion, then points out her confusion. Votes for Eonwe.

Day 2
Apologizes for Eonwe, points suspicion again at Fea. Suggests tar’s innocence. Suggests innocence of Shelob and Garin. Votes for Fea.

Day 3
Accuses Kath of bandwagoning. Suspicion of Garin. Suggests Innocence of Ang and Roa. Continues suspicion of Wayne and Garin. Votes for Gandalf. Laments what we know will happen to Garin after Crombie’s reveal.

Day 4
States desire to get rid of Cursed. Restates innocence of Ang and Roa, begins to suspect Kath again. Suspicion of Wayne and Gandalf. Votes Valier. Retracts vote. Votes Wayne – time troubles.