Tol-in-Gaurhoth XXII: Hic Monstrae Trucidant

[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by The Saucepan Man

Fair enough, but I still don’t see much substance in your contributions. Even if you don’t like Day 1s while you are in them, that is no reason not to put forward ideas, theories and speculation in the hope that it may just catch a Wolf. Only the Wolves want Day 1s to be unproductive.

I don't put forward ideas? I disagree.

Tom & Fin - for being newbies (I am right in that, huh?) who actually attempt to make sense.

Fin has played in one game before, I believe.

Any comments on my revealing the animals theory?

Originally Posted by Sauce

Those who have maintained a presence while contributing little to the debate (possible Wolves)
Form
Lommy
TGWBS
Tom
Caran

Tom??? He has posted only once! How do you call that "maintaining a presence"? Sauce, that's not your first alteration of what happened toDay. Whether they are intentional or unintentional, you scare me...

[Findëasëa]

Tom & Fin - for being newbies (I am right in that, huh?) who actually attempt to make sense.

Sorry, I missed this before. I have played in one game.

Any comments on my revealing the animals theory?

It sounds like a good idea. Even if the animals, as I suspect, are only to be used in death-narratives of the person who supplied the animal, it would be good to put this theory to rest. The animal that I chose was the sea otter.

X-posted with SPM and Caran

[Cailín]

As far as I know, Kath prefers turtles to tortoises.

How silly! Why would she? You're right, Lommy, my mistake.

Sauce - your categorisation makes sense, though the wolves are picked randomly and most of the people have been behaving quite as usual. They stereotypically belong to one of those boxes, if you understand...

Interestingly enough, there is one person who seems to be out of her appropriate Day 1 box, and that would be Caran. I understand your motivation for placing her there and shall be observing her closely.

As for the Boro issue: I typically get slightly annoyed when someone proclaims to have a very special plan and then I don't get it, but I always viewed that as my problem. In other words, I think he's rather innocent-looking.

Why should I reveal my animal? It's a deep, heart-breaking and tragic secret! Also, it's supposed to be a surprise. And really - we won't find clues in Kath's narrative.

cross-posted with Sauce, Lommy & Caran.