WWJ IX: Psychotic Penguins: The Crossing of Helcaraxë

[Encaitare]

Originally Posted by Ang

Noone believes my Diamond theory.

Ang, if you are lynched toDay and found to be innocent, I think that people will give much more credence to your theory. Right now, it would seem that the Valier issue is more important to everyone than what would seem a personal vendetta against Diamond.

Originally Posted by Roa

Also, has anyone come up with an idea why it was Mac killed in phantom's place?

As Diamond said... because he was generally considered innocent. The more controversial villagers who remain, the easier it is for the wolf to hide. But just in case there was something more to it, I'm going over who Mac suspected through the course of the name.

Mac - post 57: wonders why Ang voted for Eonwe when Enca was even more silent

Mac - post 97: votes for Kitanna because "Kitanna to me feels worse than Lalaith"

Mac - post 113: retracts Kitanna for Boro

Mac - post 138: says Ang, Di, and Phantom are on the top half of his suspicion list; Spawn and Valier are in the lower half. Mentions how Ang defended Boromir even though Ang said the evidence against Boro is frail.

Mac - post 182: votes for Jenny, also says that Valier seems more innocent than guilty.

Mac - post 239: votes for Eonwe. Also suspects Valier, but says the loss of an innocent Eonwe is not as severe a blow as the loss of an innocent Valier.

Aaaaand... then he dies. Seeing as he barely posted all of yesterDay, it seems that the WP chose to kill him because it would leave a cold trail. Plus, the majority of players in this game have played in many games before, and therefore would know better than, as a werecreature, to kill someone who had suspected them overNight.

Oh, total side note: I just realized now that in my post 368, Kitanna obviously should not be on that list. What with her being a zombie and us having to tie her to chairs, I forgot that she's technically dead.

EDIT: Cross posted with 6 (up to and including Spawn)