WWJ X: Hithlum Zydeco Blues; Hísilómë in Hísimë

[Mithalwen]

Sorry for quietness sleep/work/traffic... first real chance to post though had a quick read at lunchtime.. need to have a retrospective look to say anything of consequence but given that our only hope is to find three wolves straight and that the wolves only have to get any innocent lynched to win.... It needs to be really a case of finding 3 wolves not 1. Not too hopeful since there are far too many people around I know to be subtle wolves to have any confidence in anyone else's innocence

For the record silence wasn't frothyness - speaking without actually saying anything was frothyness..and since you were on my tail then I had to do what I had to do...

Anyway must catch up and find out what has been happening or not.

[JennyHallu]

Originally Posted by Mithalwen

For the record silence wasn't frothyness - speaking without actually saying anything was frothyness..and since you were on my tail then I had to do what I had to do...

This phrasing seems really odd. Why do you feel you have to shake people off your tail, Mith? No one except for me has voiced any strong suspicion of you all game, and certainly nothing has been done about that suspicion. I don't think you've even garnered a vote.

[Macalaure]

First, I have to say, that Kitanna's posts today make actually sense and seem quite un-wolfish to me. Now I have to look for a new top suspect...

Second, the fact that Kuru threw away his vote is irrelevant: there was nothing reasonable he could have done with it at that time. I don't really buy his explanation for not being around earlier.

Kitanna's mention of Jenny and Kuru possibly doing wolf-on-wolf suspicions are interesting. What if the two and Eomer are the wolves? What horror must have befallen the two seeing that the to-them-known innocent Nogrod and their pal Eomer were at a draw and they were the last left to vote? Both managed to get around it, securing Nogrod's death and Eomer's survival.
This is just a theory, so don't jump at me for it.

Mac, I don't see what the problem is. One can have respect for a theory or opinion even though he may ultimately conclude that it is wrong.

Giving reasons for dismissing a respected theory has never done any harm.

edit: cross-posted with Roa