WWJ X: Hithlum Zydeco Blues; Hísilómë in Hísimë

[Macalaure]

First, I have to say, that Kitanna's posts today make actually sense and seem quite un-wolfish to me. Now I have to look for a new top suspect...

Second, the fact that Kuru threw away his vote is irrelevant: there was nothing reasonable he could have done with it at that time. I don't really buy his explanation for not being around earlier.

Kitanna's mention of Jenny and Kuru possibly doing wolf-on-wolf suspicions are interesting. What if the two and Eomer are the wolves? What horror must have befallen the two seeing that the to-them-known innocent Nogrod and their pal Eomer were at a draw and they were the last left to vote? Both managed to get around it, securing Nogrod's death and Eomer's survival.
This is just a theory, so don't jump at me for it.

Mac, I don't see what the problem is. One can have respect for a theory or opinion even though he may ultimately conclude that it is wrong.

Giving reasons for dismissing a respected theory has never done any harm.

edit: cross-posted with Roa