Disturbing scenes in the movies

Originally Posted by alatar

Think that I covered this in my SbS post. Gimli may or may not have any respect for the Uruk dead. However, this same dwarf found a Warg rider to be repulsive - smelly - and so why then would he sit upon a dead orc?

PJ just wanted his joke (note the placement of Legolas' arrow).

Do you think PJ should have been punished for this scene? If this was his idea, it was a gravely foolish one.