WWJ XI: When World's Collide

[Macalaure]

"Three cheers for the Ranger!

Cheer! Cheer! Cheer!


Kath, where did Boro say that if Naria turned out to be innocent it is likely that Lommy was not? I think you refer to this:

Originally Posted by Kath

Thinks either Lommy or Naria is suspicious, the guilt of one depending on the innocence of the other.

in your Boro-analysis. But that came from:

Originally Posted by Boro

The whole I'm suspicious of Thinlo, but if she's innocent I think Naria looks suspicious, just seems all too awkward.

There he quotes the reasons that Menel gave. It's absolutely not his own suspicion - on the contrary. It's not even saying 'if Naria's innocent Lommy is not', but 'if Lommy's innocent Naria's not'. Are you twisting Boro's words? Even if it was just a fault, it is not a good reason for a vote, though I agree that good reasons for votes are rare at the moment.
Regardless I agree with you that Lommy is worth a closer look, but this kind of reason makes me suspicious on you again.

In retrospect, Sleepy's vote for Naria yesterday is a little suspicious. Since all remaining four would have had to agree on one other suspect, it basically sealed her fate."