One of these things is not like the others...

[Estelyn Telcontar]

Originally Posted by Lalwendë

In many ways, maybe we know more about Middle-earth than Tolkien did?

What an interesting thought, Lal! That would go with his invitation to others to fill in the gaps of his legendarium. I can't help but wonder if he himself would accept Fonstad's fleshing out of his geography like he welcomed Swann's melodies to his poetry. To continue that train of thought would mean that Christopher's part in the map drawing, collecting and editing of JRRT's notes, etc. is a valid addition to that increased knowledge.

Add to that the scholarly interpretations of Shippey, Flieger, et al - we have a great deal of insight to the depths of his writing that he may not have had himself. After all, which author sees through his own psychological subconsciousness?!

I foresee a contrasting debate to that old C thread...