Werewolf XXXI: The Unknown Enemies

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

I only just read through the today's posts, so these are just immediate reactions to what I marked down while reading them through. (revising it, it is quite chaotic) Will follow after some time with forming my opinions on everyone.

Originally Posted by Macalaure

8. Mith for Xyzzy ~ This looks like throwing away, but she was encouraging everybody to follow her vote. I think it looks quite innocentish.

I marked this one, since saying "it looks quite innocentish" is quite easy way to dispatch the case. Though I wasn't suspicious about Mith for that, I would look for any possible connection between Mith&Mac, just to be sure.

Mac's post reminded me yet of something Lommy said yesterday, I marked it, so I post it here:

Originally Posted by Lommy

He looks quite bad. (Though possibly he looks too bad to be a real baddie. )

This is why I suspected Lommy in the first place. I think generally, ambivalence is the typical sign of werewolfery. "Oh, I would vote this [fellow wolf], but perhaps I am just too suspicious." "I don't know about this [innocent villager], but I just am not sure."

The problem is: a) It might be quite stupid of Lommy being a wolf to say such things as above. b) Voted for her comrade? It's dangerous because someone might jump the bandwaggon and she couldn't know the vote on Glirdan would be safe, on the other hand, early votes go often out later in the day. How could she know if the vote will win? Be she a wolf or not, true is, what Mac says, that she probably had no better option to vote at that moment. (and I don't see anything suspicious on Mac saying that... who said that? Roa?)

Originally Posted by Six

I don't think Thinlomien was using some wolf kill wolf strategy. I think that might just be a bit too open on the first day.

But she didn't know at that time, so it actually wasn't open at all. It might have played to her favor that she didn't have enough time. Cf. above.

Originally Posted by Roa

Sixth looks most innocent (especially given Glirdan's reaction)

I agree with this, though for me better argument than Glirdan's reaction is that he was one to join the Glirdan bandwaggon. If he didn't, the solitary vote of Lommy might have gone unnoticed or whatever... so I don't think Sixth guilty now. While I suspected him yesterday, I didn't want to vote for him for the "killing newbies is not nice" reason, and now, since Glirdan proved to be a wolf, I think him innocent. Though by this reason I would consider Lommy innocent as well, she was the first one to vote for Glirdan and could not be sure what it will produce, cf. above, so this suspicion lasts.

Originally Posted by Rikae

Oh, now I see why there wasn't a wolf kill. It still does give us an advantage, anyway!

You see why there wasn't a wolf kill? Tell us, why?

Oh, and one thing I just have to add:

Originally Posted by xyzzy

Who's Lommy? Is that the Thin-something-or-another-with-non-English-characters-thrown-in guy?

Yes, she is that guy.

EDIT: x-ed with Lommy's last two and Mac's