WW XXXIII - Other Minds and Hands

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Two mediums? Huh.

Evidently the wolves wanted a two-for-one kill; it's extremely lucky for me that Aganzir was bluffing about being a hunter, as I'd be so much dead meat right now. xD

I'm almost positive that Gil is a wolf, but I'll let others have their say before I vote.

Edit: Wow, x'ed with Gil. xD I think you beat me by, like, a millisecond.

[Diamond18]

Wow. Slow day.

Okay, well that was interesting. So, if I recall what Volo said correctly, the medium gets riddles and it's up to them to figure out what it means. This narration seems to point to Agnazir interpreting the riddle incorrectly (And when the first wolf finally pinned her down on the ground, she looked in its eyes and suddenly understood - too late - what the phrase the ghostly Professor had sent the night before had meant.) This makes me inclined to believe that Shasta is innocent because apparently Agnazir believed him to be a wolf.

So that leaves Gil, Kath, and Ang. Of those three, I find Gil and Ang to be the most suspicious. I think there we have our last two wolves.

[Kath]

What the? Another medium? If I ever mod again I'm having just the simple roles and all of them will be clearly shown! I mean, this is great fun, but it's also madness!

Ah so. This really sucks but I am just not going to be here for this Day for numerous RL reasons. I apologise for this because it is seriously bad timing.

For this reason I must vote now.

++DIAMOND

She has slid under my radar from the beginning. I've barely even mentioned her. She says I look innocent when most others are thinking I look guilty. I don't know, this just seems like the right thing to do. I apologise that I have no time to base this on real reasoning, but this really is the only time I'm going to be on toDay unless I can sneak maybe an hour tomorrow afternoon.

[Shastanis Althreduin]

Hmm... Kath's already admitted she's not basing her vote on reasoning, and I don't see the evidence on Diamond... Also, suspicion was drifting towards Gil and Ang. I wonder if this isn't a desperation ploy by Kath to deflect suspicion on a teammate? If we don't execute a wolf today, we lose. Period.

Gil's highest on my suspicious list for his last minute retraction a few days ago, losing us Volo. Then there's Kath, who cast a critical vote just now for the one person whom there's no evidence on. Then Ang, who also made a retraction for Volo a few days ago. Then Diamond, who really hasn't done much of anything.

Right now, I'm torn between Gil and Kath.

[Gil-Galad]

I mean, this is great fun, but it's also madness!

Maddness!? THIS IS WEREWOLF!!!!


just had too

so, diamond has one vote now and everyone else is split between basically me and Ang..., well shasta is between me and Kath


++Ang


i suggest for the rest of you to not vote for any one else, focus on the two that have been voted for, ang or diamond... or be idiots and vote for someone different and have a mass suicide, that will definately show who the wolves are...

[Anguirel]

Gil, "focus on Ang and Diamond" is a ridiculous statement that only a wolf would make. Our votes are retractable - once - and we still have considerable leeway. You are attempting to limit our choices. To me, that screams out your guilt.

Now, the obvious question - did Aganzir know anything at her death? Look over her remarks. It looks a bit like she cleared me, hadn't dreamt of Kath and was preparing to dream of Shasta.

Also, let's think about the wolf rationale here. Did they doubt Aganzir's Hunter claim, in which case Shasta might still be guilty? Was Shasta innocent, allowing them to attack in the expectation of two dead innocents and victory? Did they disbelieve Aganzir's claim and know she'd got it wrong about Shasta?

Why slip into instinct voting now (particularly Gil, who hasn't even any excuse?) This day is crucially important and we need to start reasoning. Look at the dead wolves and their relationships with the suspects...

I trust Diamond, am unsure about Shasta, think Kath looks opportunistic and Gil guilty as sin.

I have failed to convince many of you of my own good intentions; but I think the medium might have cleared me, and I can also remind you that, at the time the wolf Macalaure was claiming to be a Seer and trying to win votes, he said I was innocent. Obviously this could be a nod to me as a fellow-wolf, but that would be a quite risky course of action...

[Anguirel]

Still silence?

I can explain that, I suppose -

Kath is away ( and probably wouldn't talk much as a wolf)

Shasta and Diamond are fairly quiet by disposition (in this game anyway)

I am busy and lazy

Gil is staying schtum which is exactly what he would, as a wolf, do at this point.

I have to act to provoke some action...

++GIL