Werewolf Four and Thirty: Bloodbath in the Anduin Vale

[Volo]

Drat! Not only did I just inspect Legate, but I nearly made a good case against him.
Well, back to inpecting him to find some answers to whom he dreamt about.

Do you think think that the Priestess of Sauron was more than just a Cobbler? Does it feel a bit Seerish too?

I think we can forget the Assassin. This deffinitely looks like a Bear or something wicked.

Anyway, I'll go to sleep. But just noting that Nogrod is either extremely lucky or Innocent. And that at the moment Feanor and Mith look lynch-worthy.


EDIT: Xd with Lommy

[Volo]

Off by memory (as I just read through everything by Legate, two times), I'd say that he dreamt of Boromir - Innocent.

[Volo]

Ok, let's say something about Feanor and Mith.

Feanor: No suspicions or help what so ever. Hey, if you want us to love you, give a reason. Votes easy prey. Not helpful - not Wolf? Well, she herself opposed that logic...

Mith: Many posts. Content? No. Nothing at all really. Her suspcions go as the trend goes, or at least follow my thoughts. Both votes safe.


EDIT: Xd with Lommy

[Thinlómien]

Volo - have you dropped your eccentric style or not? Clearing that up would help a lot.

edit: xed with Aggie

[Volo]

When examening Kath, it should be done very carefully.

Kath hasn't given much straight-forward suspicions either.

Day1 is pretty much 0 as the suspicions go. Votes Rikae in post #55.

Day2 is also just as wierd. Suspects Sixth and Lommy in post #131.

But my notes say that that is about it... Don't feel like analysing her closer.¨


EDIT: Xd with both ladies.

[Thinlómien]

Didn't Kath suspect Noggie as well?

[Volo]

Originally Posted by Agoyanzir

Unless the assassin doesn't kill every Night.

So evilly? It really looks like the work of some really evil creature if you ask me, unless Sir SPM wants to confuse us.

Originally Posted by Thlommy

Volo - have you dropped your eccentric style or not? Clearing that up would help a lot.

Yeah. Bad habit.

Originally Posted by Thlommy

Didn't Kath suspect Noggie as well?

*slap* Sure, my notes were made early during Day2. No wonder I didn't mention that...

[Volo]

Originally Posted by Agoyanzir

I guess he dreamt of either Boro or Rikae, since they seemed to be the ones he trusted the most. This would however point rather to Rikae:

Good catch! Maybe even too good, eh? But then again, I've caught you Innocent for gloating before...

Indeed looks like Rikae is one worth being suspected of being Innocent.

[Volo]

Oh. Dang. Rikae IS Innocent. *slap*

[Aganzir]

Originally Posted by Volo

So evilly? It really looks like the work of some really evil creature if you ask me, unless Sir SPM wants to confuse us.

Yep. What I meant was that on Night 1 there were three kills, and now only two (and we have no real knowledge who killed on Night 1). There may be an assassin who killed no one toNight.

[Volo]

Originally Posted by Aganzir

Yep. What I meant was that on Night 1 there were three kills, and now only two (and we have no real knowledge who killed on Night 1). There may be an assassin who killed no one toNight.

True. Though it looks much more that this Night lacked the Durelin mess.

Argh. Good night. Like you can see, I'm getting a bit drowsy here.


EDIT: Xd with Fea

[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by Volo

Yeah. Bad habit.

So does that mean yes or no?

[Thinlómien]

And we can't even assume that wolves killed Legate because he was getting too close as it's not sure if it was the wolves who killed Legate or someone else... And I don't know if we should drop the idea of two rival wolf teams (maybe 2 wolves per team) yet...

[Volo]

Originally Posted by Thinlómien

So does that mean yes or no?

Yes. And next you'll ask "yes what?".

I dropped the thing.


And what seems pretty probable is that the two kills are organized by one band. And there is at least one great Seer-hunter in the band of Wolves.

It looks a bit improbable that both the Seer and the Seer's dream are killed by chance.

So, I advice you to think of who might be such a player who both looks suspicious and can find the Seer when Wolf. (the suspicious part is not even essential)


Ok, now pretty truly good night.


EDIT: Xd with Lommy.

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Originally Posted by Volo

Feanor: No suspicions or help what so ever. Hey, if you want us to love you, give a reason. Votes easy prey. Not helpful - not Wolf? Well, she herself opposed that logic...

Hi there. You should love me because I'm so darned cute.

And the reason I haven't been around much is mostly that the cycles begin and end at 6:30 PM my time. The only computer I have access to is beyond my parents' bedroom and my mom crashes around nine (ah, old people). If I can't get on between those times, my play-time is limited to the second half of each DAY, and if something comes up (ever-likely)...

Here's my trouble: I generally only play in villages with limited roles, so I never mastered what roles are even within the possibility space of this game. I'm still crooked on a cobbler, much less thieves, priestesses, and druids.

So we have ordinary innocents (I'm ridiculously glad to see I'm not the only one, even if the only way I know is spotting dead people. For a brief moment, I was concerned that everybody had a different role and the point of the game was to kill everyone and see what happened).

We have at least one more werewolf[e].

Druid acts as seer, judging by the eyes being gouged out in the night. So our seer is dead. Is there anything to say we don't secretly have another one somewhere?

The Thief did... what?

And Sauron's Priestess was... an ally to the wolves? Maybe?

It's killing me to know that these roles existed and to have no idea at all what their point was.

Villagers screw up, wolves manipulate, seers see, hunters hunt, rangers protect, mythos steal roles. That's really as much as I've got down.

Did I miss anywhere where it told us how many gifteds there are, if not what they are?

[Thinlómien]

I think the Priestess of Sauron was some kind of cobbler, possibly with the knowledge of the wolves' identities... would that explain Kath's unsincerity?

And before anyone does that I must say I would examine Kath's posts very cautiously, if at all, since if - as I assume - she was somekind of cobbler - especially if she was one with knowledge of the wolves' identities - it can mislead us and it can mislead us a lot.

edit: xed with Volo's later post

[Aganzir]

Originally Posted by Volo

I think we can forget the Assassin. This deffinitely looks like a Bear or something wicked.

Unless the assassin doesn't kill every Night.

I guess he dreamt of either Boro or Rikae, since they seemed to be the ones he trusted the most. This would however point rather to Rikae:

Originally Posted by Legate to Rikae

Well, I don't know... Boro seems quite ok to me, but you do as well... from the beginning I feel it more like a two-innocent skirmish... though I am more sure with you than with Boro... but still he seems innocent to me...