Tol-in-Gaurhoth L: Battle of the Fandoms

[Macalaure]

My thoughts keep on going in circles...

Unless we have a successful ranger again in one of the next two nights, we only have two more chances to get it right.

Fea: I will assume she's innocent for toDay (unless somebody gives a really convincing case, or she does something really suspicious). Tomorrow I will consider her seriously, though.

Boro: Creeps. Me. Out.

Mith:

It worries me that Mac has failed to ring alarm bells at all.

That is actually pretty much what I could say about you, too. If you're a wolf, you almost deserve to win because you're playing it so smoothly. I doubt it though (for toDay, of course).

Izzy: The plain evidence looks worst for her, but I still have a bad feeling about voting her.


So there we are. Shall I vote for Boro just because he's creepy? I need a new idea from somewhere.

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

Shall I vote for Boro just because he's creepy?

I know, right? It's between Boro and Izzy for me today. Boro because he creeps me out, Izzy because after Boro, I'm out of suspects.

[Isabellkya]

Boro seems sincere in what he claims, but as Mith I think has said - him and Fea could get bold/crazy when a bored Ordo.

Mac is starting to make my skin itch.. because I don't think anyone has analyzed him yet, and he looks so darn innocent.

You'd be wasting your time lynching me.
The game would not end.

[Isabellkya]

Now I'm re-thinking Mith as a wolf - based on comments made from other people; most dead now.

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Fea

I'm willing to assume for the day that Boromir is innocent.

Originally Posted by Fea

It's between Boro and Izzy for me today.

Hmmm? Now that came kind of unexpected.

Mac is starting to make my skin itch.. because I don't think anyone has analyzed him yet

That actually makes my skin itch. I don't know how many people said they wanted to analyze me, some said it even twice, but nobody has done it so far. In fact, apart from Day1, the person who suspected me most was.... me!

Somebody analyze me already.

[Isabellkya]

Mac briefly -

I had looked at your voting, and it seems like on a few occasions you are in prime 'bandwagon' spot. As in a Wolf hopping on.
You've even pointed out that - I remember for two separate days; that the split voting was a very good way to give the wolves the power for that day.

Your voting for Sally, you weren't responsible for her death. I think that is more of in Nog's hands, for putting her at four - mainly to save himself I think.

I wonder if, you were wishing you had had some kind of suspicion voiced on the thread towards Nog[ beforehand, then you could've possibly saved Sally.

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Originally Posted by Macalaure

Hmmm? Now that came kind of unexpected.

I was fine with ignoring him until he said:

Originally Posted by B88

You don't believe me, have the guts to pull the latch and be done with me. It won't bring an end to this. Make a choice and have the nerve to execute and stand by that choice.

It seemed so knee-jerky. Just a little weird, you know? Like he's daring Mith to respond. Taunting.

Anyway, I'm quite happy with lynching either of the two I mentioned.

[Boromir88]

I think Fea's claimed to be everything in this village except a wolf, just throwing that out there.

Mac, I said I was going to have a look at you, but haven't done it because honestly it would take way too much of my time...really do you have to blabber so much? Anyway, I felt like what's the point when I'm already biased into thinking you're innocent and came to the conclusion long ago you were innocent, thus it would be a giant waste of my time. If you're a wolf, I guess I'm screwed.

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

I think Fea's claimed to be everything in this village except a wolf, just throwing that out there.

Hunny, you're definitely miscounting.

I said I was the seer, forgot we had a cobbler until the day we killed Lal, am barely aware we have a ranger, and I'm pretty sure I might have hinted in my first post that I was a wolf. Or something close to it.

But I definitely have only actually claimed to be the seer (whilst admitting at the same time I wasn't the real seer) and an ordo (which I am).