Tol-in-Gaurhoth LII: Star Crossed II: Together for Eternity - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Macalaure · 10-29-2008, 06:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Well, looking back to the first points made by Macalaure I might now see the reason:

Did it take you three hours to understand why you were annoyed, or to finally come up with a convincing backstory to your faked annoyance?

Groin ~ is barely there, and what he said today I didn't like
Aganzir ~ innocent, I think
Kitanna ~ haven't paid very much attention to her, I admit, but what I've seen so far didn't alarm me
Gollum ~ completely escaped my attention (it's good I do these lists once a day - I'd forget about half the people...)
Nogrod ~ has been exceedingly strange today. I'm pondering whether it's enough to vote for him
Brinniel ~ not worried about
Sally ~ I have a bad feeling about her - I'll rethink it tomorrow, I think
Shasta ~ not worried either
Gwath ~ not really sure, but not alarmed right now either
Rikae ~ seems more innocent than guilty
McCaber ~ ???
Fea ~ not sure, but not really suspicious right now either
Lily ~ kept herself somewhere around the edges of my argument with Nogrod, suspects him but didn't vote him... worried
Eönwë ~ I think I need to have a closer look at tomorrow. Something's strange about him
Eomer ~ I still get a baddish vibe from him, but it's not enough to vote him today

I think I'll give Nogrod the benefit of doubt for today. Sally, Eonwe, and Eomer I'm suspicious of, but I need to really make my mind up first. The same holds for Lily. This only leaves Groin out of my suspects, but I'm not sure whether he's actually evil or whether he just doesn't have a grasp at this village yet and is hindered by little time.

Hmmm...

++Groin Redbeard

Rikae · 10-29-2008, 06:34 PM

Ok, the thing I thought I remembered about Brinn turned out to be wrong.
I did, however, notice that Groin already commented on my first post early yesterDay. He shows up toDay in order to attack that post again (when it looks like he'll have some support, perhaps?) even though his points have already been made by someone else and addressed. He really looks like someone who is looking for some accusation to make that won't make any waves. The only thing in his favor, to my mind, is that this kind of playing may be too lazy to be evil.

Brinniel · 10-29-2008, 08:06 PM

Continuing where I left off...

Nogrod: Was actually rather quiet at the beginning, but now back to his typical self. While I agree with his supicions towards Sally, I disagree with his arguments against Mac. But really, he looks quite sensible. No alarm bells ringing yet.

Sally: As I mentioned, I do agree with Nogrod that Sally's been acting a bit differently. At the beginning of the game, she starts off fairly silly and later on does add a few silly bits here and there...but I'm used to a much more crazy Sally; that's her playing style. So could the serious turn in her behaviour possibly mean she's a lover?

Shasta: Has made a lot of posts without saying all that much. His vote yesterDay for Aganzir is the vote I'm least comfortable with. It was the second vote for her and I don't see much reason behind it. It feels like an attempt for a last-minute bandwagon to me. His one-liner questions/commentary in response to others' posts seem a bit forced.

Gwath: Is flying under the radar. His reasons behind voting Fea yesterDay seem rather flawed, but other than that, nothing really stands out to me.

Rikae: Focused a lot on Mac yesterDay, though not so much toDay. Nothing about her stands out as suspicious. In fact, I'd say her vote for Aganzir makes her less suspicious because with two votes, she was at risk of getting lynched...if she were a lover, it wouldn't make sense to spread out the voting even more and continue her chances of getting lynched. I just think a lover would be more concerned with keeping her and her partner in safety.

Mac: Has acquired a lot of attention. I wonder if that's because he's managed to be quite the sneaky wolf in the past. But looking at his posts, his arguments seem sensible to me and I don't see him very suspicious at all.

McCaber: Ehm...we've seen very little of him, so I can't say much. Would a lover be so uninvolved? I want to say it's unlikely, but it's possible...especially if lack of participation is unavoidable due to RL.

This is taking me a long time...so I think I'll post what I have now and finish looking at the last four in a little bit.

10-29-2008, 08:06 PM	#3
Brinniel Reflection of Darkness Join Date: Jun 2002 Location: Polishing the stars. Well, somebody has to do it; they're looking a little bit dull. Posts: 2,983	Continuing where I left off... Nogrod: Was actually rather quiet at the beginning, but now back to his typical self. While I agree with his supicions towards Sally, I disagree with his arguments against Mac. But really, he looks quite sensible. No alarm bells ringing yet. Sally: As I mentioned, I do agree with Nogrod that Sally's been acting a bit differently. At the beginning of the game, she starts off fairly silly and later on does add a few silly bits here and there...but I'm used to a much more crazy Sally; that's her playing style. So could the serious turn in her behaviour possibly mean she's a lover? Shasta: Has made a lot of posts without saying all that much. His vote yesterDay for Aganzir is the vote I'm least comfortable with. It was the second vote for her and I don't see much reason behind it. It feels like an attempt for a last-minute bandwagon to me. His one-liner questions/commentary in response to others' posts seem a bit forced. Gwath: Is flying under the radar. His reasons behind voting Fea yesterDay seem rather flawed, but other than that, nothing really stands out to me. Rikae: Focused a lot on Mac yesterDay, though not so much toDay. Nothing about her stands out as suspicious. In fact, I'd say her vote for Aganzir makes her less suspicious because with two votes, she was at risk of getting lynched...if she were a lover, it wouldn't make sense to spread out the voting even more and continue her chances of getting lynched. I just think a lover would be more concerned with keeping her and her partner in safety. Mac: Has acquired a lot of attention. I wonder if that's because he's managed to be quite the sneaky wolf in the past. But looking at his posts, his arguments seem sensible to me and I don't see him very suspicious at all. McCaber: Ehm...we've seen very little of him, so I can't say much. Would a lover be so uninvolved? I want to say it's unlikely, but it's possible...especially if lack of participation is unavoidable due to RL. This is taking me a long time...so I think I'll post what I have now and finish looking at the last four in a little bit. __________________ Nolite te bastardes carborundorum

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Switch to Linear Mode Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

10-29-2008, 06:34 PM	#2
Rikae Mellifluous Maia Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: A glade open to the stars, deep in Nan Elmoth Posts: 3,489	Ok, the thing I thought I remembered about Brinn turned out to be wrong. I did, however, notice that Groin already commented on my first post early yesterDay. He shows up toDay in order to attack that post again (when it looks like he'll have some support, perhaps?) even though his points have already been made by someone else and addressed. He really looks like someone who is looking for some accusation to make that won't make any waves. The only thing in his favor, to my mind, is that this kind of playing may be too lazy to be evil.