Tol-in-Gaurhoth LII: Star Crossed II: Together for Eternity

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Hey Greenie. Since we seem to be the only ones around, I hope you don't mind if I take a look at your suspicions and ponder how closely they match mine. I don't really have anything better to do at the moment...

I agree with the consensus that Gollum seems newbie-ish, but when I've wolved with newbies before, there's often been some sort of night-time coaching. Kind of a 'Get it together before you get us killed!' thing. I feel like if he was somebody's Lover, he'd be a bit more careful. But if he is, who do you think would be his Lover? I lean toward Brinniel because of her defense of his newbie-ishness, but that seems to easy. The best way to defend a cohort in the spotlight is to stay out of the way and hope some well-meaning innocent does the job for you. Maybe twitch a few puppet strings here and there, you know? Anyway, I lean toward Gollum being more newbie-innocent than newbie-Lover. I can be swayed on this one.

Eomer. Now he's creeptastic and manipulative. But he is whether or not he's a bad guy and I'm willing to go out on a dangerous limb and say that I see no reason why we should kill him. He stirs up trouble, yes, but he thinks a lot like me, I've noticed. He's the type that I'd like very much to keep around until the end, if you don't mind.

I definitely agree with you about Agan being innocentish. Noggin I'm not so sure. Have you ever noticed that thing where people who know a lot are a lot more capable of imagining more? Maybe that's not common knowledge. Anyway, I've mentioned it before- people who know what their roles are (beyond ordo) are more likely to be able to successfully imagine the roles of their peers. Agan? She's so settled on her thoughts about what people could be. Nog is more open to the fact that Diamond could be lying left and right, that we could have a bizillion baddies, that etctera. See what I mean? He feels innocentish, but I'm meta-paranoid. Brinn I already suggested as maybe-worrisome.

I'm totally with you on the NO IDEA -ZONE. Groin, Sally, Shasta, McCaber... I've got nothin'. Gwath feels innocentish, but I'm not sure why.

Fea - I certainly want to look at her more closely if I have the time. Unlike the others on this zone, Fea seems both innocent and evil whereas the others seem neither. All in all, she baffles me.

I know. I'm sorry. I'll explain when I can. It's just awkward.

[Brinniel]

Originally Posted by McCaber

Moving on, I'm not quite sure I like all these people with low post counts. Some of them just might not be thinking, but a few look like they're trying to hide something. I am spending valuable thought time on them, and sooner or later something will happen.

A rather hypocritical comment for you to be saying...considering you have the second lowest post count among the living.