Tol-in-Gaurhoth LIV: The Council of Evil

[Kath]

Is there any particular reason you would want to lynch sally apart from a bad feeling Agan? Because I'm getting pretty much the opposite feel on her so I'd like to know where your suspicion of her has come from.

Menel, I think your argument about someone with experience killing the wolves is a good one but I wonder how you ended up with me as a wolf when people like sally, Agan, Gwath and Shasta are also around and know the players just as well.

[Aganzir]

And there's also Eönwë who has played with probably all of us, and Bowie who hasn't played but gives the impression of being aware of what kind of players we are. And Izzy but I doubt she'd come to post a kill yet not be here in the day.

Kath it's mostly just a bad feeling about sally, but an exceptionally strong one, and I find it hard to concentrate on anyone else properly as long as sally is alive.

(Ooh by the way, lovely avvie sally. <3)

Okay I try to elaborate.

It's somehow the way sally was so keen on analysing Boro's death, and later also Nog's. Anyone could have done it; 'X would have had this reason to kill him but then again there's also this aspect...'

Originally Posted by sally

Point is, either Boro's death was random, a bluff, or a deliberate kill because of how Boro plays. Great. That tells us nothing.

And her resolution. I know she's one of the few who are being loud but still, it looks weird.

Garr I just don't know. Something in her feels wrong but I can't put my finger on it, just can't.

[satansaloser2005]

Well, sweetie, there's not terrible lots to talk about.


I just can't do anything right in these games, can I?

[Aganzir]

Sally you do, I just can't help this. It's irrational.

And with loud players dying one by one I'm not sure how much I like the idea of lynching you... However right now I feel you're my best bet.

Sorry I haven't been posting anything but currently my post count is almost twice that of anyone else's and I don't have the energy to go through the thread once again.

[satansaloser2005]

Heh. Obviously I must not, or else I wouldn't get suspected all the time. I honestly don't mind people suspecting me -really, I don't, it's part of the game- but I don't like that I'm usually suspected for no reason. Either I'm too useless or I run my gob too much. Either way I'm screwed. Bah, when life gives you lemons....you analyze werewolves!


Shasta, I'd hate to see you withdraw, especially since you're not being able to play at the moment is beyond your control. If you feel that it would be better for you to leave the game, then do so, but barring that I look forward to playing with you again when your internet connection's fixed. (Assuming we're both still alive, of course. )



I don't really have much of a main suspect toDay, sadly. Agan doesn't strike me as too off and Kath, though quiet like everyone else, isn't screaming 'WOLF!' to me either. And I'd hate to kill Bowie just to try to validate a theory.



I need to get ready for church. I'll come back to my thoughts later.

[Eönwë]

Sorry about not being here properly yesterDay. My internet died while I did have time, and then I had to go due to family-RL stuff.

I'll look at the posts so far... (not very many since I last posted, it seems)

[Kath]

I understand those inexplainable feelings Agan and it is difficult to concentrate on others when you have those bad feelings, but even if sally is a wolf she is only one of two. Given that I don't think she's a wolf it would make me feel better about you if you could maybe look at some other people, or even how others have interacted with sally to try and find evidence for her possible wolvishness that way. I'm sorry I don't meant to throw instructions at you but like you said you are one of our remaining loud players and we need you!

I missed Gwath's post earlier and reading it through just now it does seem a little odd. I agree that if either the wolves or the bear is actually failing to kill then it is more likely to be the bear as I doubt both wolves are missing in action. However, from what I know of the werebear role it has the choice of whether to kill or not so I don't think that the lack of kills on that front point to an absent player. In addition I would actually think that the bear is an experienced player who actually wants to win as the bear. A lot of the time evil creatures get caught in these games via the Nightly kills, an experienced player would know that and might be letting the wolves do all the work in the hope that they get caught and then the bear can just walk off with the victory.

[Strongbow]

Well, here's my piece (and my 100th post!):

I am suspect because I know how people act, and I said I was suspicious of Boro early on, which leads some to believe that my partner might be one of our absentees. Well, to prove my innocence, I'm willing to vote for myself in the event that more suspicion falls on me. Wolf gambit? You decide. If I do end up being lynched, please write me a good suicide scene Gollum.

Before I move on, I'd like to say that in my experience, the posting fillerish things without contributing to discussion is a tactic used by the enemy, to say "Oh! I'm active, don't kill me! I'm active, so I must be innocent!" Because of the general lack of substance, I can't tell if this is just being idle, or being sinister. I do not post just for the sake of posting. I post to make serious analysis. If this reduces my overall post count, so be it.

Agan, in her last post, tries to validate herself by saying that she has double everyone else's posts, when I feel that a few of those are not entirely necessary. This being said, I'm not feeling with overt strength that she's furry, but I'm not neglecting the possibility.

Sally isn't very much better. I don't really see the use in posting vote counts at this stage, because of the general lack of votes. I can't be sure if it's a ploy to legitimize yourself, but I'm not going to point any fingers until I see more...anything, really.

Gwath's post doesn't add anything very earth shattering, and doesn't really pique my curiosity.

Kath is starting to get reception, but I can't get a reading.

Menel, are you there? You post little, and when you do, it isn't much. Hmmm...

Eonwe is my kin, but isn't saying anything worthy of note. Yet.

Isabell and Shasta are obviously off our radar.

Edited for format.