T-I-G LV Sing when you're winning

[Boromir88]

At least Cailin said she wasn't the Divo. So no disaster should you choose that route.~tp

Wouldn't that point to her innocence? The only last-ditch defense critics and Walter have left is the divo? Unless if Walter has no more useful information to drop at night and has decided to give up?

[Aganzir]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

Wouldn't that point to her innocence? The only last-ditch defense critics and Walter have left is the divo? Unless if Walter has no more useful information to drop at night and has decided to give up?

Or she's saying it for the sake of bluffing. Or Walter-Cailín wants to get killed instead of a critic.

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Mac

They all need to have "exit strategies" in their plans.

I agree. The safest way to approach things would be never to be on Fea's side in the first place. Or perhaps to support lynching Fea all day, but towards the deadline begin to waffle, and act like they think they are making a mistake, and then be proven totally wrong (with ignorance pointing towards innocence).

Originally Posted by Boro

Wouldn't that point to her innocence?

Yep.

Originally Posted by Boro

Unless if Walter has no more useful information to drop at night and has decided to give up?

Nah. As far as we know, Walter can still do the whole self-vote-to-clinch-game thing, so why not stick around and do it. The only thing Walter definitely wants at this time is not to be Night-killed. So I imagine about now he's hoping for a bit of suspicion to come his way, to preserve him through the Night. He's still useful, either as an opera-clincher, or at the least lynch fodder to protect the Critics.

[Kath]

Kath - I was leaning innocent with her, but her insisting that the cobbler should be lynched before we try to lynch critics made her sky-rocket.

YesterDay we lynched Fea under the assumption that she was the Cobbler not a Critic. We turned out to be even luckier but still.

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Kath

YesterDay we lynched Fea under the assumption that she was the Cobbler not a Critic. We turned out to be even luckier but still.

And if she had been the cobbler and Aganzir a critic it would have been a clear mistake.

[Boromir88]

I'm not the divo either! ~Mac

Well then...

++Mac

Now are you?

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

Now are you?

No, I'm still not the divo.

[Kath]

And if she had been the cobbler and Aganzir a critic it would have been a clear mistake.

No because had Agan been a Critic then we'd have lynched her toDay. The only reason we didn't lynch her was because she had evidence that she was something else. Therefore we'd have lynched both the Cobbler and a Critic in two Days, its not a bad rate of getting baddies.

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Agan

I don't think saying she's not the diva points to Cailín's innocence.

Yes it does. It definitely does.

But that doesn't mean that she is innocent. It could mean she is guilty, but is well aware that such a statement would point to her innocence, and so she makes it.

[Boromir88]

I don't think saying she's not the diva points to Cailín's innocence. Just because it seems like a natural thing to say when in danger of being killed.~Agan

Well the ultimate hope for the critic would be to draw out the real divo, not necessarily to save themselves. This would assume however the critics don't know who the divo is, and is just trying to draw them out so not to waste a kill.

If they already know, I agree, but because they probably wouldn't want to draw the divo out giving us a known innocent.

[Aganzir]

I don't think saying she's not the diva points to Cailín's innocence. Just because it seems like a natural thing to say when in danger of being killed. Plus I could have said so, regardless of my role, if in the same situation.

++Mac

edit: xed with Mac

[Macalaure]

++Sally

I think she's more suspicious than Gollum, and those two are the only ones that could save me, though I very much don't like following Gwath's vote.